Live on XaptiqUGC NET Economics (Dec 2026) and IIT JAM Economics (EN) test series are now live on Xaptiq.View test series
BusinessEnergy > Power MarketsIndian EconomyInfrastructureClimate Finance

States pay up to Rs 41.50 a unit for evening power as grid strains

Six States are buying extra winter power through short-term tenders at Rs 8.99 to Rs 41.50 a unit, as India's evening shortfall reached 5.8 gigawatts (GW) in October.

What happened

Gujarat, Rajasthan, Maharashtra, Madhya Pradesh, Tamil Nadu and Keralam have sought additional power for November and December through short-term tenders. Prices range from Rs 8.99 to Rs 41.50 per unit (kWh), according to the Ministry of Power's DEEP (Discovery of Efficient Electricity Price) portal. This power is over and above what the States draw under their long-term power purchase agreements (PPAs). Most States have not secured the full quantity they sought, despite offering higher prices. The evening power shortfall reached as high as 5.8 GW in October.

Context

The squeeze comes in the evening, when solar generation falls and limited battery storage cannot shift daytime power to the peak. Industry insiders link this year's surge in short-term buying to unusual weather tied to El Niño, higher irrigation demand and more industrial activity. Peak power demand has touched 270 GW this year. In the north, the grid operator has warned that solar flows from Rajasthan are overloading the lines that carry them. The Ministry of New and Renewable Energy (MNRE) estimates the renewable sector needs $220 billion of investment between FY27 and FY30, including $40-45 billion for transmission.

Why it matters

India's power problem is shifting from total energy to timing. During the day, solar output is plentiful. In a September 30 letter, the National Load Despatch Centre (NLDC), the national grid operator, warned that transformers at Moga in Punjab, Bhiwani in Haryana and Jhatikara in Delhi are loaded beyond the N-1 limit during solar hours. N-1 is the reliability standard that keeps the grid running if any one component fails. The Northern Region recorded a maximum demand of 95,027 MW on July 16.

In the evening, solar output fades and States must find power elsewhere. Distribution companies usually cover most needs through PPAs that can span 25 years. They meet extra demand through power exchanges or short-term tenders, which fix a quantity and period but cost more.

The tender data show how scarce evening power is. Tamil Nadu sought 1,000 MW for November and was allotted only 377 MW. For December, 361 MW of its 401 MW comes at Rs 41.50 per unit. Rajasthan tendered 1,500 MW for November and secured 85 MW. Madhya Pradesh was the exception: it bought its full 800 MW for November 20 to February 15 at Rs 3.99 to Rs 5.50 per unit.

The fix is storage and transmission rather than more daytime capacity. MNRE Secretary Santosh Sarangi said the government recognises the need to speed up battery energy storage to manage discoms' peak demand.

Impact for India

  • State discoms: paying up to Rs 41.50 per unit for marginal power raises their costs, and unfilled tenders leave a risk of evening shortages.
  • Consumers and industry: costly short-term power feeds into discom finances and, eventually, tariffs.
  • Northern grid: transformers at Moga, Bhiwani and Jhatikara run beyond the N-1 limit in solar hours, raising the risk of disruption if a component fails.
  • Renewable investment: transmission alone needs $40-45 billion of the $220 billion MNRE estimates for FY27 to FY30.
  • Storage developers: the evening gap strengthens the case for battery energy storage.

Key data

Short-term tender prices, November-December: Rs 8.99 to Rs 41.50 per unitMadhya Pradesh: Rs 3.99 to Rs 5.50 per unit
Evening power shortfall, October: 5.8 GW
Tamil Nadu, November tender: 377 MW allotted1,000 MW sought
Rajasthan, November tender: 85 MW allotted1,500 MW sought
Renewable investment need, FY27-FY30 (MNRE): $220 billionTransmission: $40-45 billion

Concepts

Power purchase agreement (PPA)A long-term contract under which a distribution company buys power from a generator at agreed terms.The tenders are for power over and above what States draw under PPAs that can span 25 years.
Peak demandThe highest electricity load in a period; it decides how much capacity the system needs.The shortfall is concentrated in the evening, after solar output falls.
N-1 criterionA reliability standard under which the grid keeps working normally if any single component fails.NLDC says transformers at Moga, Bhiwani and Jhatikara breach it during solar hours.

Theory lens

Peak-load pricing — when capacity is fixed and demand varies through the day, the price of a unit at the peak should reflect the scarce capacity it uses, while off-peak units pay little more than running cost. The tender prices follow this logic: evening and round-the-clock power fetches up to Rs 41.50 per unit, while Madhya Pradesh's winter contract cleared at Rs 3.99 to Rs 5.50. The gap is the market's price of evening capacity, and the case for storage that moves solar power into those hours.

Stakeholders

Gains: Generators with spare evening capacityShort-term tenders pay up to Rs 41.50 per unit.
Gains: Battery storage and transmission developersThe evening shortfall and line overloads point to investment in storage and grid capacity.
Pressure point: State distribution companies (discoms)They pay high short-term prices and still cannot secure the full quantity.
Pressure point: Tamil Nadu's discomIt is buying 361 MW for December at Rs 41.50 per unit.

Practice Question — from the story

With reference to short-term power procurement by States and grid stress in 2026, consider the following statements:

  1. Madhya Pradesh secured only a fraction of the 800 MW it tendered for, paying up to Rs 41.50 per unit.
  2. The National Load Despatch Centre warned that transformers at Moga, Bhiwani and Jhatikara were loaded beyond the N-1 limit during solar hours.

Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

  1. 1 only
  2. 2 only
  3. Both 1 and 2
  4. Neither 1 nor 2
Reveal answer & explanation

Answer: 2 only

  • Statement 1: Incorrect. Madhya Pradesh was allotted its entire 800 MW at Rs 3.99 to Rs 5.50 per unit; Rs 41.50 is what Tamil Nadu is paying for December.
  • Statement 2: Correct. NLDC's September 30 letter flagged these transformers as breaching the N-1 limit in solar hours.

Therefore, the correct answer is 2 only.

Concept check — test your understanding

Why does a power system with a large share of solar capacity tend to face shortages in the evening rather than at midday?

  1. Because solar panels produce less in winter, so daytime supply is what falls short.
  2. Because solar output fades after sunset while demand stays high, and limited storage cannot shift daytime power into the evening.
  3. Because long-term power purchase agreements bar distribution companies from buying power after dark.
  4. Because power exchanges stop trading in the evening, so distribution companies cannot buy spot power.
Reveal answer & explanation

Answer: B

  • Peak demand persists after sunset just as solar generation falls, and without enough battery storage the daytime surplus cannot meet the evening gap.
  • A is partly true about seasons but misses the daily timing; the shortfall is in the evening even when midday solar output is plentiful.
  • C is wrong: PPAs set contracted supply, and States buy extra evening power on top of them.
  • D is wrong: exchanges and short-term tenders are exactly how discoms buy extra power for these hours.