Parliament panel presses Centre and States on CAG-flagged fraud in SC scholarships
Parliament's Public Accounts Committee (PAC) has given the Social Justice Ministry a month to report action on leakages the CAG flagged in Scheduled Caste scholarships, which cost ₹52,878 crore in 2017-24.
What happened
The Public Accounts Committee (PAC) of Parliament on October 15 questioned the Union and State governments over gaps, including fraud markers, that the Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) found in pre- and post-matric scholarships for Scheduled Caste (SC) students. The Chief Secretaries of six States did not appear, and the committee may move privilege notices against them. The Social Justice Ministry said implementation rests with the States, which had not shared action-taken reports. The PAC gave the Ministry one month to report on each issue.
Context
The CAG's 2025 report found that 40.75 lakh beneficiaries in 14 States received scholarships late, with delays of one to 90 months, and over 3.5 lakh received nothing. Over 5,700 scholarships were paid without proper income checks and over 6,000 went to non-SC beneficiaries. Both schemes are centrally sponsored, with costs shared 60:40 between the Union and the States, or 90:10 for northeastern States. From 2017-24, ₹52,878 crore was spent on them, about ₹30,234.5 crore of it the Union government's share.
Why it matters
Centrally sponsored schemes split the money from the management: the Union pays most of the cost while States run the scheme. That makes accountability easy to pass back and forth, which is what happened at the hearing, with the Ministry saying it could not file action-taken reports because States had not sent them. The audit also tests the claim that Direct Benefit Transfer (DBT) with Aadhaar-linked payments removes fake beneficiaries. The PAC pointed to fraud markers that survived it: one caste certificate used by several beneficiaries in Uttar Pradesh, payments to seemingly common bank accounts in Odisha, and over ₹13 crore paid in Haryana where Aadhaar and bank details did not match. Meanwhile the shift to DBT cut the number reached: the post-matric scheme covered 36.07 lakh students in 2025-26 against a target of 76.55 lakh. The scheme is making both kinds of targeting error at once.
Impact for India
- SC students: Delays of up to 90 months for 40.75 lakh beneficiaries and non-payment to over 3.5 lakh weaken a scheme meant to keep them in education.
- Union government: It funded about ₹30,234.5 crore of the ₹52,878 crore spent in 2017-24 and must now file action-taken reports within a month.
- States: The Chief Secretaries of Uttar Pradesh, Karnataka, Punjab, Odisha, Bihar and Madhya Pradesh face possible privilege notices for not appearing.
- Welfare delivery: Fraud markers persisting under DBT and the Aadhaar Payment Bridge System show that payment technology alone does not verify eligibility.
- Parliamentary oversight: The PAC is using the CAG audit to force a scheme-by-scheme accounting from both levels of government.
Key data
Concepts
Theory lens
Principal-agent problem - when one party (the principal) funds an activity carried out by another (the agent) whose effort it cannot fully observe, the agent's incentives can drift from the principal's goals. In SC scholarships the Union is the principal, paying about ₹30,234.5 crore, while States are agents running the scheme. Missing action-taken reports and absent Chief Secretaries show how weak monitoring blunts the principal's control.
Stakeholders
Practice Question — from the story
With reference to the pre-matric and post-matric scholarship schemes for Scheduled Caste students, consider the following statements:
- The schemes are centrally sponsored, with costs shared 60:40 between the Union and the States, and 90:10 for northeastern States.
- In 2025-26 the post-matric scheme reached 36.07 lakh beneficiaries against a target of 76.55 lakh.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
Reveal answer & explanation
Answer: Both 1 and 2
- Statement 1: Correct because both schemes are Centrally Sponsored Schemes with that cost-sharing ratio.
- Statement 2: Correct because the PAC noted that the shift to Direct Benefit Transfer cut beneficiary numbers, and the 2025-26 post-matric figure reached only 36.07 lakh against a target of 76.55 lakh.
Therefore, the correct answer is Both 1 and 2.
Concept check — test your understanding
A welfare scheme pays some people who are not eligible, while some eligible people receive nothing. In the language of targeting, these two failures are respectively called:
Reveal answer & explanation
Answer: D
- An inclusion error brings an ineligible person into the scheme; an exclusion error leaves out an eligible one, as with the over 6,000 non-SC recipients and over 3.5 lakh unpaid students.
- Option A swaps the two terms, the most common slip when learning them.
- Option B mixes a delivery concept with a tax-efficiency one: leakage is close to inclusion error, but deadweight loss is the efficiency cost of a tax or price distortion, not missed beneficiaries.
- Option C names information problems from insurance and credit markets, which can cause targeting failures but are not the names of the failures themselves.