PAC flags ₹9,222 crore cess shortfall in reserve fund transfers
The Public Accounts Committee questioned the Finance Ministry over ₹9,222 crore in 2024-25 cess collections that never reached the four reserve funds they were meant to finance, reviving a warning first flagged in the panel's 69th Report of 2023.
What happened
The Public Accounts Committee (PAC) on September 8, 2026 pressed the Union Finance Ministry over an audit finding that ₹9,222 crore of cess and levy collections in 2024-25 were not transferred to four designated reserve funds. The finding sits in Paragraph 3.3.1 of the CAG's Report No. 6 of 2026. PAC chair K.C. Venugopal said the committee had raised the same objection in its 69th Report in August 2023, and that ignoring parliamentary standing-committee directions amounted to an insult to Parliament.
Context
Cesses are levied for a stated purpose and are ring-fenced from the divisible pool of central taxes, so they are not shared with States under Finance Commission awards. The Consolidated Fund of India receives cess proceeds and Parliament authorises their onward transfer to statutory reserve funds. In 2024-25 the Centre collected ₹3,89,220 crore in cesses, charges and levies, or 10.25% of its gross tax revenue. The audit found the largest gap in the Pradhan Mantri Swasthya Suraksha Nidhi, and a long-running shortfall in the Oil Industry Development Fund going back to 1974-75.
Why it matters
A cess loses its constitutional purpose the moment its receipts blur into general revenue. When Health and Education cess money is not credited to PMSSN, the specific health facility the levy was justified by does not get built, yet the cess has already been collected from every taxpayer. Because cesses bypass the divisible pool, they let the Centre raise revenue without sharing it with States — so an unspent cess reserve is both a fiscal-federalism issue and a Consolidated Fund of India accounting issue.
Impact for India
- Union Finance Ministry: Must reconcile audit-flagged gaps in revised estimates for 2025-26 and defend the practice of parking cess receipts in the Consolidated Fund of India.
- States: A rising share of central revenue coming through non-divisible cesses shrinks the pool that is devolved under the Finance Commission formula.
- Reserve funds (PMSSN, OIDF, MUSK): Under-transfers delay the specific spending they were designed to finance — hospital upgrades, oil-industry infrastructure, higher-education outlays.
- Ordinary taxpayers: Bear the cess on fuel, income and services regardless of whether the earmarked service is delivered.
- Parliament: PAC precedent and 69th Report recommendations are being tested against executive practice.
Key data
Concepts
Theory lens
Fiscal earmarking and public choice — earmarking taxes to specific spending purposes is meant to raise willingness-to-pay by linking a levy to a visible service, and to constrain the executive's ability to redirect the money. When cess receipts are not transferred to their designated reserve fund, the earmarking becomes cosmetic: the levy is collected on the earmarking rationale but spent on general obligations, so the political-economy trade the taxpayer accepted is unwound. Public-choice analysis predicts exactly this drift when parliamentary oversight over intra-government transfers is weaker than oversight over the original taxing power.
Stakeholders
Practice Question — from the story
With reference to cesses levied by the Union government, consider the following statements:
- Cess collections are not part of the divisible pool of central taxes and are therefore not shared with States under the Finance Commission formula.
- Cess proceeds credited to the Consolidated Fund of India can be transferred to statutory reserve funds only through parliamentary authorisation.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
Reveal answer & explanation
Answer: Both 1 and 2
- Statement 1: Correct because cess and surcharge collections sit outside the divisible pool of central taxes and are therefore not shared with States under Finance Commission awards.
- Statement 2: Correct because reserve funds are financed from the Consolidated Fund of India through budgetary support, grants, cesses and levies, and any withdrawal from the CFI requires parliamentary authorisation.
Therefore, the correct answer is Both 1 and 2.
Concept check — test your understanding
In Indian public finance, what makes an earmarked cess constitutionally distinct from an ordinary Union tax?
Reveal answer & explanation
Answer: B
- Option B is correct: a cess is legally tied to a stated purpose (e.g. Health and Education cess for PMSSN and MUSK), and the enabling Union law keeps cess proceeds outside the divisible pool that is devolved to States under the Finance Commission formula.
- Option A is misleading: cesses on Union subjects do not need State legislature approval; they are enacted under Union legislative competence.
- Option C is a common misconception: cesses do not carry an automatic constitutional five-year sunset — they lapse only when Parliament amends or repeals the enabling law.
- Option D flips the actor: States can levy their own cesses and surcharges, but the cesses under discussion in the PAC audit are Union levies collected by the Centre.