CAG flags ₹3,541 crore excess spend, ₹15,586 crore parked in Ladki Bahin scheme
The CAG's State Finances Audit Report 2024-25 says Maharashtra spent ₹3,541.16 crore in excess on its Ladki Bahin scheme and parked ₹15,586 crore drawn from the treasury in deposit accounts — a breach of budgetary discipline, and a warning on welfare-transfer fiscal design.
What happened
The Comptroller and Auditor General's State Finances Audit Report 2024-25 for Maharashtra, tabled in the state legislature on Friday, flagged excess expenditure of ₹3,541.16 crore on the Mukhyamantri Majhi Ladki Bahin Yojana. The Women and Child Development Department spent ₹33,237.24 crore against the authorised budget of ₹29,693.09 crore. That ₹29,693.09 crore grant itself was built through ₹26,200 crore of supplementary provisions and ₹3,490.75 crore re-appropriated from the Lek Ladki Yojana. Between January and March 2025, ₹15,586 crore drawn from the treasury was transferred to Virtual Personal Deposit Accounts (VPDAs) — the CAG called this a “serious financial irregularity” that undermined legislative control over public finances.
Context
The Ladki Bahin scheme, approved on June 28, 2024, pays ₹1,500 per month through Direct Benefit Transfer to eligible women aged between 21 and 65 years, with the stated aim of ensuring women's economic independence. Expenditure on women's welfare in Maharashtra rose from ₹261.78 crore in the previous year to more than ₹33,500 crore — a step-change the CAG described as “a significant shift toward welfare-oriented transfers rather than capital asset formation”. The audit also observed “significant deficiencies in budget estimation, expenditure control, and financial management” in the scheme's implementation.
Why it matters
The audit surfaces two distinct problems that generalise beyond Maharashtra. First, welfare-transfer schemes are absorbing budget space that could otherwise fund capital asset formation — the CAG's phrasing frames this as a shift from capital to revenue expenditure. Second, parking withdrawn funds in Virtual Personal Deposit Accounts sidesteps the parliamentary principle that money is drawn from the treasury only when needed for actual expenditure. The CAG called it “contrary to principles of budgetary discipline and financial propriety” — a specific fiscal-federalism red flag as similar cash-transfer schemes proliferate across states.
Impact for India
- Maharashtra state finances: A recurring outlay of more than ₹33,500 crore locks in a large committed transfer, crowding out capital expenditure headroom.
- Beneficiary women: The DBT of ₹1,500 per month continues; the audit concerns are about the disbursement architecture, not the individual entitlement.
- CAG and state auditors: The Virtual Personal Deposit Account episode strengthens the case for tighter treasury drawal norms across states that run large DBT schemes.
- Other states copying the model: The audit is a template for how similar Ladli-style schemes elsewhere may show up in state audit reports.
- Legislative oversight: A ₹3,541.16 crore breach without specific justification undermines the annual budget's role as an ex-ante spending cap.
Key data
Concepts
Stakeholders
Practice Question — from the story
With reference to the Maharashtra government's Mukhyamantri Majhi Ladki Bahin Yojana and the CAG's State Finances Audit Report 2024-25, consider the following statements:
- The CAG flagged excess expenditure of ₹3,541.16 crore on the scheme, over an authorised budget of ₹29,693.09 crore.
- The authorised ₹29,693.09 crore grant for the scheme was built through ₹15,586 crore of supplementary provisions and ₹3,490.75 crore re-appropriated from the Lek Ladki Yojana.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
Reveal answer & explanation
Answer: 1 only
- Statement 1: Correct. The CAG's State Finances Audit Report 2024-25 flagged excess expenditure of ₹3,541.16 crore on the Ladki Bahin scheme against the authorised budget of ₹29,693.09 crore.
- Statement 2: Incorrect. Supplementary provisions accounted for ₹26,200 crore, not ₹15,586 crore. The ₹15,586 crore figure is the amount drawn from the treasury between January and March 2025 and parked in Virtual Personal Deposit Accounts — a separate CAG concern, not part of the composition of the grant.
Therefore, the correct answer is 1 only.
Concept check — test your understanding
The CAG noted that Maharashtra's Ladki Bahin scheme reflects "a significant shift toward welfare-oriented transfers rather than capital asset formation". In Indian public finance, direct benefit transfers of this kind are typically classified as:
Reveal answer & explanation
Answer: A
- Revenue expenditure covers government spending that does not create a physical or financial asset — salaries, subsidies, interest payments, and cash transfers. That is precisely why the CAG contrasts these transfers with "capital asset formation".
- Option B misuses the accounting term: even if the DBT is framed politically as "investment", it does not build an asset the government owns and so is not capital expenditure.
- Option C confuses "off-budget" (spending routed outside the budget, e.g. via PSU borrowings) with "in-budget but funded via supplementary demands", which is what happened here.
- Option D is a common misconception: committed expenditure conventionally means salaries, pensions and interest — items where legal or contractual obligations lock spending in — not discretionary welfare schemes that a future budget can rescale.