Cash transfers to women carry a political cost, not just a fiscal one
Unconditional cash transfer schemes to women have become a signature electoral strategy since 2020, yet targeting errors — real and perceived — impose a distinct political cost that has coincided with incumbent losses, argue K. R. Shanmugam and Sankarganesh Karuppiah.
What happened
Unconditional Cash Transfer (UCT) schemes have become a central electoral strategy in India since 2020, particularly to attract women voters, yet several sponsoring governments have lost office despite raising the payouts before the 2026 elections, argue K. R. Shanmugam of the Madras School of Economics and Sankarganesh Karuppiah of the Indian Revenue Service. Writing in The Hindu, they cite the Kalaignar Magalir Urimai Thittam in Tamil Nadu, Lakshmir Bhandar in West Bengal, Gruha Lakshmi Yojana in Karnataka and Mukhya Majhi Ladki Bahin Yojana in Maharashtra, and estimate — citing the Ministry of Finance's latest Economic Survey — that States are expected to spend about $18 billion on UCTs in 2025-26.
Context
The Kalaignar Magalir Urimai Thittam illustrates the design tension. The ruling party promised ₹1,000 per month to all women-headed households before the 2021 election, but fiscal constraints led the government to restrict eligibility by income, land ownership and other criteria when the scheme launched in September 2023. It initially covered about 1.13 crore women, with another 16.94 lakh beneficiaries added in December 2025 after widespread complaints. The scheme cost ₹13,807 crore in 2025-26. Lakshmir Bhandar (2021) faced allegations of covering non-residential citizens; expansion did not prevent the incumbent's defeat.
Why it matters
The authors describe an inherent tension between economics and politics. Economics favours targeted programmes so scarce public resources reach those most in need; politics rewards broad inclusion because voters judge governments both by what they receive and by what they believe was unfairly denied. Because most informal-sector incomes cannot be observed, governments use proxies — land, electricity use, household assets — that generate both inclusion and exclusion errors. The economic cost of targeting is well-studied; the argument here is that the political cost is being systematically under-priced.
Impact for India
- State finances: rising UCT bills crowd out productive spending on employment and self-employment programmes and require expenditure switching or wider fiscal deficits.
- Sponsor parties: even accurate targeting produces aggrieved excluded voters, so competitive welfarism becomes politically self-defeating over time.
- Beneficiaries: once households come to depend on a UCT, withdrawal is politically difficult — locking in a recurring liability.
- Alternative programme design: conditional cash transfers and self-selecting schemes such as Tamil Nadu's Midday Meal reduce grievance because participation is tied to a socially desirable behaviour like school enrolment.
- SDG frame: UCTs partially advance SDG 5.4 by recognising women's unpaid domestic and care work, but that gain sits alongside the fiscal and political costs.
Key data
Concepts
Theory lens
Political-economy of redistribution — public choice theory notes that voters evaluate governments not only on benefits received but also on benefits they believe were unfairly denied, so any means-tested transfer with imperfect observability generates a political-cost residual. The authors apply this to UCTs: even administratively accurate targeting produces excluded voters who see the denial as unfair, and the marginal shift in constituencies where 2021-launched schemes were expanded pre-2026 illustrates the mechanism.
Stakeholders
Practice Question — from the story
With reference to unconditional cash transfer (UCT) schemes for women in India, consider the following statements:
- The Kalaignar Magalir Urimai Thittam was launched in September 2023 with monthly transfers of ₹1,000 to all women-headed households without any means test.
- The Ministry of Finance's latest Economic Survey expects States to spend about $18 billion on unconditional cash transfers in 2025-26.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
Reveal answer & explanation
Answer: 2 only
- Statement 1: Incorrect — the ₹1,000-a-month payout was a 2021 pre-election promise for all women-headed households, but when the scheme launched in September 2023 fiscal constraints forced the government to restrict eligibility by income, land ownership and other criteria.
- Statement 2: Correct — the authors cite the Ministry of Finance's latest Economic Survey estimating that States will spend about $18 billion on UCTs in 2025-26, much of it targeted at women.
Therefore, the correct answer is 2 only.
Concept check — test your understanding
In the Indian context, why do targeted, means-tested unconditional cash transfer schemes typically generate both inclusion and exclusion errors?
Reveal answer & explanation
Answer: C
- Correct: informal-sector income is unobservable, so eligibility is inferred from proxy variables (land, electricity, household assets) that map imperfectly to actual income — producing both false positives (inclusion errors) and false negatives (exclusion errors).
- Distractor A inverts the well-known incentive: informal workers typically under-report, not over-report, income when a benefit is at stake.
- Distractor B misapplies the FRBM Act, which caps fiscal deficits but has nothing to say about the design of welfare eligibility.
- Distractor D describes a common misconception: even a corruption-free, fully digital transfer would still suffer targeting errors because the underlying income data is missing, not merely misrecorded.