EU's carbon border tax lands on India as a steel bill
The EU starts collecting its carbon border tax in February 2027. Iron and steel make up $5.4 billion of the $6.3 billion of Indian exports it touches, so India's exposure is narrow but deep.
What happened
BRICS leaders adopted the New Delhi Declaration on September 12, and paragraph 108 opposes 'unilateral, punitive, discriminatory and protectionist measures', naming carbon border adjustment mechanisms as an example. The Global Trade Research Initiative said the reference was plainly to the EU, the only bloc charging such a tax today. The EU began applying the charge at its borders from January 1, 2026, covering iron and steel, aluminium, cement, fertilisers, hydrogen and electricity. Importers start buying certificates from February 2027 for goods shipped during 2026. Certificates cost a little over €75 a tonne of carbon dioxide in the first two quarters of this year.
Context
Europe charges its own factories for the carbon dioxide they release, which makes untaxed imports cheaper by comparison. The Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM) closes that gap at the border. Making a tonne of steel in India releases 2.54 tonnes of carbon dioxide against a world average of 1.9 tonnes, so a tonne of Indian steel carries carbon worth roughly €190 on paper. The charge will climb each year as Europe withdraws the free permits it gives its own mills, a withdrawal scheduled between 2026 and 2034.
Why it matters
Whether CBAM cuts emissions or only moves them is the heart of the BRICS objection. ICRIER finds that global steel emissions would fall by about 1% while the EU's own emissions rise by 0.29%, because European mills simply make more steel to fill the gap. Production shifts from India to Europe and the atmosphere is left where it was. Meanwhile the revenue is real: Brussels wants 75% of CBAM proceeds, about €1.4 billion a year, to go to the EU budget, and the European Commission has proposed a €100-billion Industrial Decarbonisation Bank for European factories. Nimish Singh and Shivang Agarwal note that India has produced about 3.6% of all carbon dioxide emitted since 1751, against almost a fifth for the EU's member states.
Impact for India
- Steel exporters: ICRIER estimates the tax could cut India's steel exports to the EU by 24%, and Commerce Ministry figures already show a 13% fall in iron and steel shipments to the bloc in the first four months of the new regime.
- The Article 9 opening: If a mill pays a carbon price at home, the European importer can subtract that amount at the border, so India can choose whether the payment happens in Delhi or in Brussels.
- The perverse result: India's Carbon Credit Trading Scheme caps emissions per unit of output rather than charging for every tonne, so a mill that stays within its limit pays nothing at home and therefore gets nothing subtracted in Europe, while a mill that overshoots does pay and gets a discount.
- Steel targets pending: The Environment Ministry issued draft targets for 255 iron and steel plants only on June 26, skipping the 2025-26 compliance year, with a median cut in emissions per tonne of about 5.5%.
- Recognition gap: The UK put the Indian scheme on its list of qualifying carbon pricing schemes on September 8 for its own border tax starting in January 2027; the EU has not.
Key data
Concepts
Theory lens
Pigouvian taxation — an externality is corrected by charging the polluter a price equal to the damage the pollution causes, so the private cost of production rises to meet the social cost. CBAM extends that logic across a border: the carbon price follows the good rather than the factory. The catch is that a Pigouvian tax only corrects the externality if it reaches all the damage. ICRIER's finding that EU emissions rise 0.29% while world emissions fall about 1% suggests the charge is relocating production more than it is pricing carbon.
Global context
The UK has moved faster on recognition than the EU. On September 8, its treasury put the Indian scheme on the list of qualifying carbon pricing schemes for its own border tax starting in January 2027. Brazil has also engaged more heavily with the rule-making: when the Commission sought comments on the draft rules, India sent three responses, all from private firms, while Brazil sent 12, two of them filed jointly by federal ministries.
Stakeholders
Practice Question — from the story
With reference to the European Union's Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM), consider the following statements:
- The EU began applying the charge at its borders from January 1, 2026, but importers will start buying certificates only from February 2027.
- Of the $6.3 billion of CBAM-covered goods India sold to the EU in 2024, aluminium accounted for $5.4 billion.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
Reveal answer & explanation
Answer: 1 only
- Statement 1: Correct. The charge applies to goods shipped from January 1, 2026, while the obligation to buy certificates begins in February 2027, covering those 2026 shipments.
- Statement 2: Incorrect. Iron and steel, not aluminium, accounted for $5.4 billion of the $6.3 billion. This is why India's CBAM exposure is described as narrow but deep, and in effect a steel bill.
Therefore, the correct answer is 1 only.
Concept check — test your understanding
A carbon border adjustment charges imported goods for the carbon released in making them. Which problem is such a mechanism principally designed to address?
Reveal answer & explanation
Answer: B
- A domestic carbon price raises the cost of making steel at home but not abroad. Without a border charge, output and emissions relocate rather than fall, which is carbon leakage. The border adjustment is meant to make the carbon price follow the good instead of the factory.
- Option A names a real consequence, not the rationale. Revenue does flow to the EU budget and a decarbonisation bank has been proposed, but a mechanism designed purely to raise revenue would not need to be calibrated to embedded carbon.
- Option C describes an industrial-policy or supply-security goal. It is an adjacent motive often attributed to CBAM, but the instrument is built around emissions content, not import dependence.
- Option D misreads how the Paris framework works. Nationally determined contributions are self-set and carry no enforcement mechanism of this kind; CBAM is unilateral EU law, which is exactly what the BRICS declaration objected to.