India's rice exports carry a hidden groundwater cost, economists argue
India ships more than twice as much non-basmati rice as basmati but earns only marginally more from it, and much of it is grown on scarce groundwater, argue economists A.V. Manjunatha and Vikram Patil. They want rice exports judged by value per unit of water and carbon, not tonnes shipped.
What happened
India's rice exports should be judged by the water and carbon they use, not only by tonnes and dollars, argue economists A.V. Manjunatha of the Institute for Social and Economic Change and Vikram Patil of the International Rice Research Institute. India produced an estimated 154.02 million tonnes (mt) of rice in 2025-26 and has been the world's largest exporter since 2012, with about 30-35% of global exports in recent years. Exports rose from 17.73 mt in 2020-21 to 21.57 mt in 2025-26, and their value from $8.82 billion to $11.54 billion. In 2025-26, non-basmati exports of 15.04 mt earned ₹51,892 crore, while basmati exports of 6.52 mt earned ₹50,138 crore. The authors propose a water-carbon-value framework to guide export policy.
Context
Every tonne of rice exported carries the water used to grow it, known as virtual water. Rice raised on rainfall, called green water, puts little strain on local resources. Rice grown on water pumped from aquifers, rivers and reservoirs, called blue water, draws down a scarce stock. The pressure is greatest in Punjab, Haryana and western Uttar Pradesh, but groundwater-fed rice in parts of West Bengal, Bihar, Odisha, Chhattisgarh, Telangana, Andhra Pradesh, Tamil Nadu and Karnataka adds to it. Rice also has a climate cost: flooded fields release methane, and heavy use of nitrogen fertiliser adds other greenhouse gases. Over the six years from 2020-21 to 2025-26, basmati exports averaged 5.16 mt worth $4.97 billion a year, against 14.74 mt of non-basmati worth $5.71 billion.
Why it matters
The authors' point is that export earnings hide what is used up to produce them. Non-basmati rice brings in about the same money as basmati for more than twice the volume, so it earns far less per tonne and, where it is grown on groundwater, far less per unit of scarce water. When rice from depleting aquifers is shipped abroad, India is in effect exporting groundwater that is not priced in the sale. The authors do not ask India to export less rice. They ask it to export better rice: diversify towards less water-intensive crops in water-stressed areas, improve irrigation efficiency, and raise value through quality, branding, traceability, processing and geographical indications. Practices such as alternate wetting and drying and direct-seeded rice can cut emissions and water use, though results vary by soil and climate. To measure progress, they propose tracking export value per tonne and per cubic metre of blue water, groundwater used per tonne, emissions per kg of rice and farmer income per unit of water.
Impact for India
- Groundwater: paddy grown on pumped water in Punjab, Haryana and western Uttar Pradesh draws down aquifers that are already under stress.
- Export policy: the authors want export earnings judged by value per unit of water and carbon, not volume alone.
- Farmers: diversification incentives in water-stressed areas would shift some farmers away from paddy.
- Climate: methane from flooded fields and nitrogen fertiliser use add to India's farm emissions.
- Rice trade: with about 30-35% of global exports, India's choices affect world rice supply.
Key data
Concepts
Theory lens
Trade theory says a country exports goods that use its abundant factors intensively, which is the Heckscher-Ohlin idea. India's rice exports look odd by that test, because many rice-growing regions are short of water. The puzzle is resolved by pricing. When an input is not priced at its scarcity value, a country can appear to have a comparative advantage in a good that uses it heavily. Groundwater is an open-access resource: each farmer pumps as much as they want, no one bears the full cost of a falling water table, and the aquifer is overused, the tragedy of the commons. Export earnings then overstate the gains from trade, because they leave out the depletion of a natural stock. Green accounting addresses this by counting resource depletion as a cost, much as the authors' water-carbon-value framework would. The policy response follows from the diagnosis: price or limit the scarce input, or reward output that uses less of it.
Global context
India has been the world's largest rice exporter since 2012 and accounts for about 30-35% of global rice exports. Its decisions on what to grow and where therefore matter beyond its borders. A shift towards fewer tonnes of higher-value rice would change the supply available to importing countries that rely on Indian non-basmati rice, which is why the authors frame the goal as better exports, not fewer.
Stakeholders
Practice Question — from the story
With reference to India's rice exports in 2025-26, consider the following statements:
- Non-basmati rice exports were more than twice basmati exports by volume.
- Basmati rice exports earned more in rupee terms than non-basmati rice exports.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
Reveal answer & explanation
Answer: 1 only
- Statement 1: Correct. Non-basmati exports were 15.04 mt against 6.52 mt of basmati.
- Statement 2: Incorrect. Non-basmati exports earned ₹51,892 crore against ₹50,138 crore for basmati, only marginally more despite the larger volume.
Therefore, the correct answer is 1 only.
Concept check — test your understanding
Why does the 'blue water' embodied in India's rice exports matter more for sustainability than the 'green water'?
Reveal answer & explanation
Answer: A
- Correct. The authors say policy should ask how much scarce blue water exports embody, not how much rice is shipped.
- Water source does not set grain quality; the value gap is between basmati and non-basmati varieties.
- Rainfall is not charged for at all; irrigation charges apply to canal water, and the problem with groundwater is that it is rarely priced.
- Methane comes from flooded fields whatever the water source; it depends on how long fields stay flooded.