Poverty may be far above World Bank's 2.6%, thali test suggests
About 30% of Indians cannot afford two simple home-cooked meals a day, argue economists Pulapre Balakrishnan and Aman Raj, using the same consumption survey from which the World Bank estimated extreme poverty at 2.6%. They say the poverty line needs rethinking and that rising food prices need urgent attention.
What happened
About 30% of Indians cannot afford two square meals a day, argue economists Pulapre Balakrishnan and Aman Raj in The Indian Express, a figure hard to square with the World Bank's estimate that extreme poverty in India is 2.6%. Their measure, the thali index, counts how many thalis a person can buy with the monthly spending on food reported in the Household Consumption Expenditure Survey (HCES) for 2023-24. They price a thali at ₹30, CRISIL's estimate of the cost of a home-cooked vegetarian thali in 2023-24. On this basis, up to 50% of rural Indians and 20% of urban Indians cannot afford two thalis a day. Counting the value of subsidised food lowers these shares to 40% and 10%.
Context
The World Bank's estimate is a headcount ratio: the share of the population below a poverty line. It applies that line to the same HCES 2023-24 data, but the report does not say which goods and prices make up the line for India, the authors note. So both numbers come from one survey and differ in method. The World Bank measures income poverty against a money line, while the thali index looks directly at how much food people consume. The authors first proposed the thali index in 2025.
Why it matters
The gap between 2.6% and about 30% turns on what a poverty line should guarantee. A household above the line in money terms may still eat too little, because rent, medicines and school fees have to be paid first, which leaves food as whatever money remains. If two meals a day is the minimum acceptable level of food, the authors argue, the World Bank's line is too low for India. This matters for policy. A very low poverty figure can breed complacency: if extreme poverty has nearly gone, there seems little need for policies against it. The authors link food adequacy to prices. Food inflation rose every month between January and September, tripling over the period, so the food budgets of the poor are under pressure now. They call for an urgent review of policies to control food inflation and argue that, over time, only higher farm productivity can supply more food at steady prices.
Impact for India
- Poverty measurement: a food-adequacy test points to about 30% of people unable to afford two meals a day, against the World Bank's 2.6%.
- Welfare policy: a low headline poverty figure could weaken the case for food and income support while food prices are rising.
- Food inflation: food inflation tripled between January and September, cutting how much food poor households can buy.
- Agriculture: lasting control of food prices, the authors argue, needs higher farm productivity.
Key data
Concepts
Theory lens
Engel's law and food as the residual item — Engel's law says the share of income spent on food falls as income rises, which is why many poverty lines are built around the cost of a minimum diet. The authors' argument turns this around for the poor. When rent, medicines and school fees are fixed commitments, food becomes the item that adjusts, so a household can sit above a money-based poverty line and still eat too little. Amartya Sen's capability approach makes a similar point: being adequately nourished is itself a measure of well-being, not just a use of income. On that view, a poverty line is only as good as the consumption it actually secures, and a direct test of food adequacy is a check on whether the line is set high enough.
Historical parallel
India has argued about where to draw the poverty line for decades. The early official lines were anchored on the spending needed to buy a minimum number of calories. The Tendulkar committee moved to a broader basket that also allowed for spending on health and education, and the Rangarajan committee later raised the line again. Each revision changed the count of the poor sharply, so the choice of line has always been as much a policy judgment as a statistical one. The thali index revives the older, food-based test against the World Bank's money-based line.
Stakeholders
Practice Question — from the story
With reference to the measurement of poverty, consider the following statements:
- The headcount ratio is the share of the population living below the poverty line.
- The headcount ratio does not show how far below the poverty line the poor are.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
Reveal answer & explanation
Answer: Both 1 and 2
- Statement 1: Correct. The headcount ratio divides the number of poor by the population, as in the World Bank's 2.6% for India.
- Statement 2: Correct. It only counts the poor. Measures such as the poverty gap index capture how far below the line they fall.
Therefore, the correct answer is Both 1 and 2.
Concept check — test your understanding
The thali index and the World Bank's 2.6% extreme-poverty estimate use the same HCES 2023-24 data. Why do they reach very different results?
Reveal answer & explanation
Answer: D
- The World Bank compares total spending with a money line; the thali index checks food spending against the cost of two ₹30 thalis a day.
- Both use consumption spending from the same survey; neither uses income data.
- The World Bank estimate covers the whole country, not only rural households.
- Even after counting subsidised food, the thali index still finds about 30% unable to afford two meals, so imputation does not close the gap.