Free and subsidised goods lift 22 crore people into higher consumption classes
Counting the value of free and subsidised goods, such as foodgrains, moves about 22 crore Indians, or 15.8% of the population, into a higher consumption class, finds a Ministry of Statistics and Programme Implementation (MoSPI) staff paper.
What happened
About 22 crore people, or 15.8% of the population, saw their level of living improve once in-kind social transfers were counted, a MoSPI staff paper finds. Using the 2022-23 Household Consumption Expenditure Survey (HCES), the authors compared each household's consumption class with and without the estimated value of free or subsidised goods such as foodgrains, laptops, bicycles and school uniforms. The share was 18.8% in rural areas and 8.4% in urban areas. West Bengal was highest at 40.5%, followed by Chhattisgarh (29.2%), Assam (29%) and Karnataka (28.4%).
Context
This is the first time the statistics ministry has tried to value free or subsidised items given to households through welfare programmes. The paper, by Amitava Saha and Gopal Saha of the National Statistics Office (NSO), carries a note that its opinions are the authors' own. It does not value free medical services under the PM Jan Aarogya Yojana or free education, and the authors say including them would have shown further gains, mostly for lower consumption classes. With the transfers counted, average rural monthly spending per person rose to Rs 3,860 from Rs 3,773.
Why it matters
Consumption surveys measure what households spend. A family that receives free grain spends less on food, so its recorded spending understates how well it actually lives. Imputing the value of in-kind transfers corrects part of that gap. The paper also tests targeting: the largest upward movement is in the bottom three consumption classes, which the authors read as evidence that the transfers are progressive, reaching the poor rather than the rich. Getting consumption right matters because poverty and inequality estimates are commonly built on consumption data.
Impact for India
- Poverty measurement: Estimates based only on cash spending may overstate deprivation where in-kind transfers are large, especially in rural areas.
- Welfare targeting: Upward movement of 4-33% across rural consumption classes and 1-22% across urban ones, concentrated at the bottom, supports the case that the schemes reach intended beneficiaries.
- States: The spread from West Bengal at 40.5% to other major States shows that the reach of in-kind transfers differs widely across States.
- Statistical system: The method gives the NSO a template that could be extended to health and education services, which this paper leaves out.
Key data
Concepts
Theory lens
Vertical equity and progressive transfers — a transfer is progressive when it raises the living standards of poorer households by proportionately more than those of richer ones, which narrows inequality. The MoSPI paper finds the maximum upward movement in the bottom three consumption classes in both rural and urban India. On that measure, in-kind transfers act as a redistributive tool aimed at the poor, which is what targeted welfare is designed to do.
Stakeholders
Practice Question — from the story
With reference to the MoSPI staff paper on in-kind social transfers and household living standards, consider the following statements:
- The paper's estimate includes the value of free medical services available under the PM Jan Aarogya Yojana.
- The share of the population moving to a higher consumption class after counting in-kind transfers was higher in urban areas than in rural areas.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
Reveal answer & explanation
Answer: Neither 1 nor 2
- Statement 1: Incorrect because the study does not estimate the value of free medical services under the PM Jan Aarogya Yojana or free education.
- Statement 2: Incorrect because the share was 18.8% in rural areas against 8.4% in urban areas.
Therefore, the correct answer is Neither 1 nor 2.
Concept check — test your understanding
Why can adding the imputed value of free or subsidised goods to household consumption change measured living standards?
Reveal answer & explanation
Answer: B
- A household that gets free grain spends less on food, so its recorded spending understates its consumption; adding the imputed value corrects that, which is how about 22 crore people moved up a class.
- Option A gets the price effect backwards for recipients and is not how the imputation works.
- Option C is a plausible confusion: the imputation changes the household's measured consumption, not the poverty line itself.
- Option D mixes up income and consumption; consumption surveys measure spending, and in-kind transfers add no cash.