India's climate targets ask too little and need an absolute cap, argues Ritwick George
India keeps beating its climate pledges because they ask little more than it would do anyway, argues Ritwick George. He wants an absolute emissions cap, generation-based targets and faster grid building.
What happened
India's climate pledges ask little more than the country is already on track to achieve, argues Ritwick George, a former researcher at ISB's Bharti Institute of Public Policy. India promised 40% non-fossil power capacity by 2030 and got there in 2021, nine years early. It raised the target to 50% in 2022 and cleared it in 2025. Its new pledge of 60% clean capacity by 2035 compares with nearly 53% already reached in February.
Context
Nationally Determined Contributions (NDCs) are the national pledges at the heart of the Paris Agreement. India also pledged to cut the emissions intensity of its economy by 33-35% from 2005 levels, and met that goal early. Its new target is a 47% cut in intensity by 2035. George writes that this needs less than half the annual pace of improvement India has managed so far. He argues the case ahead of COP31, which opens in Antalya on November 9.
Why it matters
The core argument is about the metric. Emissions intensity measures carbon per unit of GDP, so total emissions can rise while intensity falls. George's example: if an economy doubles while cutting intensity by 40%, it still emits 20% more. China adopted its first absolute target last year, and he calls India the largest emitter in the Paris Agreement without one.
Capacity is also a weak measure of clean power. India has over 50% clean capacity, but clean sources supplied just 29% of its electricity last year. Coal still generates more than two-thirds. George cites a Reuters report that India wants 307 gigawatts of coal capacity by 2035, 46% more than in 2025.
He links climate policy to energy security. India imports 88% of its crude oil, and about half its crude imports pass through the Strait of Hormuz. Clean power is now cheaper at the margin. Madhya Pradesh bought battery-backed solar at Rs 2.70 per kWh, and round-the-clock clean power bid at Rs 5.25, against Rs 5.38 to Rs 6.30 for 2025 coal contracts. The IEA estimates a clean-energy path would cut India's oil import bill by $1.4 trillion over two decades.
His three proposals are a peak year and an absolute limit for power-sector emissions, targets for clean electricity generated rather than capacity installed, and faster transmission building. India built only about 80% of its planned transmission capacity over the past five years.
Impact for India
- Climate diplomacy: the argument for a stronger NDC lands ahead of COP31.
- Power sector: the proposals would shift targets from installed capacity to generation.
- Coal planning: a plan for 307 GW of coal by 2035 sits in tension with clean-energy goals.
- Transmission: grid building lags plans, so clean power is curtailed.
- External balance: electrifying transport and cooking would cut exposure to imported oil.
Key data
Concepts
Theory lens
Intensity versus absolute targets — an intensity target caps emissions per unit of output, while an absolute target caps total emissions. Under an intensity target, growth can raise total emissions even as intensity falls. George's example shows the gap: an economy that doubles while cutting intensity by 40% emits 20% more. That is the basis for his call for an absolute limit on power-sector emissions.
Stakeholders
Practice Question — from the story
With reference to India's clean-energy and emissions targets, consider the following statements:
- India reached its target of 40% non-fossil power capacity in 2021, nine years ahead of the 2030 deadline.
- Clean sources supplied 29% of India's electricity last year, although clean capacity was over 50%.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
Reveal answer & explanation
Answer: Both 1 and 2
- Statement 1: Correct. The 2030 target of 40% non-fossil capacity was met in 2021.
- Statement 2: Correct. Clean sources supplied 29% of electricity despite over 50% of capacity, which is why the writer wants generation-based targets.
Therefore, the correct answer is Both 1 and 2.
Concept check — test your understanding
A country's GDP doubles while its emissions intensity, emissions per unit of GDP, falls by 40%. What happens to its total emissions?
Reveal answer & explanation
Answer: B
- Total emissions equal intensity times output, so doubling output while cutting intensity by 40% leaves emissions 20% higher, which is the writer's case for an absolute cap.
- A ignores output growth; intensity and total emissions diverge when GDP grows.
- C assumes the two changes cancel, but a 40% cut does not offset a doubling.
- D gets the direction wrong by comparing percentages instead of multiplying the two factors.