India's unbuilt capital stock makes today's investment choices decide future emissions
With 86% of the buildings India will have in 2070 still unbuilt, standards set in today's investment will fix future emissions, argue economists Amarendu Nandy and Aayush Anand.
What happened
Most of the capital India needs for its next phase of growth is yet to be built, so its future emissions depend on what it builds now, argue Amarendu Nandy of IIM Ranchi and Aayush Anand. NITI Aayog estimates that 86% of the building stock India will have in 2070 is yet to be built. Steel capacity is targeted to rise from about 200 million tonnes to 300 million tonnes by 2030-31. The authors propose efficiency codes, transmission planning and green public procurement.
Context
The United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) has warned that the world could cross the 1.5°C warming threshold within the next few years. India's total floor space will more than double, from about 18 billion square metres in 2020 to 42 billion by 2070. Cement output is projected to rise from about 427 million tonnes in 2024 to 660 million tonnes by 2030. The Ministry of Power plans roughly 590 GW of generation additions between 2023 and 2032.
Why it matters
The usual reading is that India's infrastructure deficit makes decarbonisation harder. The authors turn it around: an unbuilt capital stock is a choice, not an inheritance. Assets built now will last decades, so standards embedded at construction avoid costly retrofits and stranded assets later.
They match the instrument to the sector. In buildings the technology exists and the gap is implementation: the Energy Conservation Building Code (ECBC) 2017 has been notified by 27 States but legally incorporated in only 21. In power, the International Energy Agency (IEA) estimates transmission bottlenecks have held back around 60 GW of renewable capacity, so the grid must be planned alongside or ahead of new generation.
In steel and cement, where green technology is not yet viable at scale, they warn that mandating a technology could lock firms into processes that later prove uneconomic. Public procurement is their preferred tool. Tenders could set emissions-intensity thresholds without prescribing the production route, letting competitive bidding reveal the green premium. Thresholds could then tighten as costs fall and align with the Carbon Credit Trading Scheme (CCTS).
Impact for India
- States and urban bodies: embedding ECBC and the 2024 building codes in permits, occupancy certificates and grid connections would make non-compliance costly.
- Power sector: transmission and storage need to be planned ahead of roughly 590 GW of new generation, or more renewable capacity stays stranded.
- Steel and cement makers: emissions-intensity thresholds in public tenders would create an early market for lower-emission materials without mandating a route.
- Public buyers (Railways, NHAI, State agencies): their bulk purchases of steel and cement become a lever for decarbonisation.
- Clean-energy developers: a cost of capital about 80% higher than in advanced economies can make viable projects uneconomic; credit guarantees or concessional debt can help.
Key data
Concepts
Theory lens
Putty-clay capital — before installation, capital can take any technology and input mix (putty), but once built its technology and energy use are fixed for its lifetime (clay). The authors' case rests on this: India's steel, cement, buildings and grid are mostly still putty, while the EU's buildings are clay. Choices embedded now, such as efficiency codes and emissions-intensity thresholds, decide emissions for decades, which is why they argue against both inefficient building and premature technology mandates.
Global context
Advanced economies face the opposite problem — the IEA estimates that around 80% of the building stock they will use in 2050 already exists. In the European Union, 85% of buildings predate 2000, around three-quarters perform poorly on energy efficiency, and only about 1% are renovated each year. That leaves Europe decarbonising through slow, costly retrofits, whereas India can build efficiency in from the outset.
Stakeholders
Practice Question — from the story
With reference to India's building, power and industrial investment and its emissions, as argued in a recent analysis, consider the following statements:
- The Energy Conservation Building Code 2017 has been notified and legally incorporated by 27 States.
- The International Energy Agency estimates that transmission bottlenecks have held back around 60 GW of renewable capacity in India.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
Reveal answer & explanation
Answer: 2 only
- Statement 1: Incorrect. The code has been notified by 27 States but legally incorporated in only 21, according to the Bureau of Energy Efficiency's State Energy Efficiency Index.
- Statement 2: Correct. The IEA estimates that around 60 GW of renewable capacity has been held back by transmission bottlenecks.
Therefore, the correct answer is 2 only.
Concept check — test your understanding
Why does a high cost of capital hurt clean infrastructure such as solar or wind power more than fossil-fuel plants of similar output?
Reveal answer & explanation
Answer: B
- Clean infrastructure is front-loaded in cost: the capital outlay comes first and fuel costs are near zero, so the interest rate on that capital drives the levelised cost. A fuel-heavy plant spreads more of its cost over its operating life.
- A describes risk perception, which can raise borrowing rates, but it does not explain why the same rate hurts capital-heavy projects more.
- C is a misconception: solar and wind assets are long-lived, which is why lock-in arguments apply to them too.
- D misleads on emphasis: the analysis traces the problem to cost structure, with clean projects front-loaded in cost, not to how tariffs are set.