Oil companies drop cane-juice ethanol from tenders; Karnataka seeks a rethink
Oil marketing companies' ethanol tender for 2026-27 leaves out ethanol made from sugarcane juice, sugar syrup and B-heavy molasses, a sugar-rich by-product. Karnataka wants that reversed and the sugar floor price, stuck at ₹31 per kg since 2019, raised.
What happened
Karnataka Chief Minister D.K. Shivakumar has written to Prime Minister Narendra Modi seeking urgent intervention for sugarcane farmers. In the tender issued by oil marketing companies (OMCs) on October 16, 2026, for November 2026 to October 2027, ethanol produced from sugarcane juice, sugar syrup and B-heavy molasses was excluded, while ethanol from C-heavy molasses remains eligible. He asked the Centre to reconsider the exclusion, raise the price of cane-based ethanol, revise the Minimum Selling Price (MSP) of sugar and reset the base recovery rate for the Fair and Remunerative Price (FRP) to 9.5%. Farmers' protests have delayed the crushing season in North Karnataka.
Context
The MSP of sugar, the floor price for mills' sales, has stayed at ₹31 per kg since February 14, 2019. Over the same period the FRP, the minimum price mills must pay for cane, rose from ₹2,750 to ₹3,650 per tonne. Prices for ethanol from sugarcane juice and B-heavy molasses have not changed since 2022-23, while grain-based ethanol prices have risen. The base recovery rate used to calculate the FRP was raised in stages from 9.50% to 10.25%. Karnataka has an annual production capacity of 225 crore liters of sugarcane-based ethanol. A committee headed by farm scientist Ramesh Chand is examining farmers' issues.
Why it matters
Mills are caught between administered prices that move at different speeds. They buy cane at an FRP that rises every year, sell sugar against a floor frozen since 2019, and sell cane-based ethanol at prices fixed since 2022-23. Ethanol made directly from cane juice or B-heavy molasses gives mills a second revenue stream besides sugar. Dropping those feedstocks from the 2026-27 tender narrows that stream, which the Chief Minister says will hurt mills' ability to pay farmers on time. The higher base recovery rate adds a second squeeze. Where cane yields less sugar because of soil, climate or crushing time, farmers receive less than the base FRP.
Impact for India
- Sugar mills: the Chief Minister says the exclusion is likely to cut their revenue and their ability to make timely payments to farmers.
- Cane farmers: payments are at risk, and standing cane loses weight and sugar content every day the crushing delay lasts.
- Ethanol supply: among cane-based feedstocks, only C-heavy molasses remains eligible in the OMC tender for November 2026 to October 2027.
- Households: farm groups propose separate sugar MSPs for domestic and bulk commercial buyers, to protect household consumers.
- Centre-State relations: Karnataka will install digital load cells and order monthly inspections of mills, but says the main demands can only be met by the Centre.
Key data
Concepts
Theory lens
Administered pricing — when the state fixes both an input price and an output price but revises only one, the firm in the middle absorbs the gap. The FRP for cane rose from ₹2,750 to ₹3,650 per tonne, while the sugar MSP stayed at ₹31 per kg and cane-ethanol prices stayed at 2022-23 levels. Closing the cane-juice ethanol channel removes one way mills had to make up the difference, so the pressure passes to farmer payments.
Stakeholders
Practice Question — from the story
With reference to sugarcane pricing and the oil marketing companies' ethanol tender for 2026-27, consider the following statements:
- The tender excludes ethanol produced from C-heavy molasses while keeping ethanol from sugarcane juice eligible.
- The Minimum Selling Price of sugar has stayed at ₹31 per kg since February 14, 2019, while the FRP for sugarcane has risen from ₹2,750 to ₹3,650 per tonne.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
Reveal answer & explanation
Answer: 2 only
- Statement 1: Incorrect because it is the reverse: ethanol from sugarcane juice, sugar syrup and B-heavy molasses is excluded, while ethanol from C-heavy molasses remains eligible.
- Statement 2: Correct because the Chief Minister's letter states the sugar MSP has been ₹31 per kg since February 14, 2019, while the FRP rose from ₹2,750 to ₹3,650 per tonne.
Therefore, the correct answer is 2 only.
Concept check — test your understanding
Raising the base recovery rate used to calculate the Fair and Remunerative Price (FRP) for sugarcane affects farmers mainly because:
Reveal answer & explanation
Answer: D
- The FRP is linked to a base sugar recovery rate, and cane recovering below it earns a lower price, so a higher base pushes more farmers below the full FRP.
- A higher base rate does not raise the FRP for everyone; it makes the full price harder to qualify for.
- The domestic sugar floor is the separate Minimum Selling Price of sugar, not the recovery rate.
- Diversion of cane to ethanol is shaped by OMC tenders and ethanol prices, not by the FRP recovery rate.