India's ethanol push runs into a maize bind and a sugar-price spike
India hit its E20 blending target five years early, but the programme is now buckling: maize has flipped India from a net exporter to a net importer, sugar mills are losing money on ethanol they must sell below cost, and distilleries are running at half capacity even as sugar prices surge to a nine-year stock low.
What happened
Two data points sit uncomfortably together. India, having hit its 20% ethanol blending (E20) target in 2025 — five years ahead of the 2030 schedule — is now paying ₹71.86 a litre for maize-based ethanol, the highest rate for any feedstock, even as a litre of crude oil costs about ₹55 with Brent near $70 a barrel and under ₹45 in calmer markets. Separately, sugar retail prices have jumped from ₹45/kg on July 21 to ₹65/kg on August 22 as gross sugar output for 2025-26 was cut to 309 lakh tonnes (lt) from an original 343.5 lt estimate, and closing stocks are heading to a nine-year low of about 41 lt.
Context
India has run ethanol-blended petrol since 2006, when the blend was 5%. The 20% target — E20 — came out of NITI Aayog's June 2021 'Roadmap for Ethanol Blending in India 2020-25', which argued that sugarcane alone could not carry the target and pushed the shift to less water-intensive feedstocks like maize. Maize now supplies close to half of the ethanol India blends into petrol, up from almost nothing three years ago. Counting maize plus surplus FCI rice and damaged foodgrains, grain feedstock produces nearly 70% of India's ethanol; sugarcane routes have fallen to 32% of ethanol supplied to oil marketing companies during November 2025 to July 2026.
Why it matters
The programme is caught in a three-way squeeze that shows up as textbook policy tradeoffs. First, energy security versus food security: 127 lakh tonnes of maize — close to a third of production — is now contracted for ethanol, so poultry and feed users (for whom feed is 60-70% of production cost) are importing maize from Myanmar and Ukraine, and India became a net maize importer in 2024 for the first time in decades. Second, administered prices versus rising costs: sugarcane's guaranteed grower price is up 16.5% since 2022 while the fixed procurement price of B-heavy molasses ethanol is frozen at ₹60.73/litre against a production cost of about ₹66/litre. Third, the fiscal claim is real — the government says blending has saved over ₹1 lakh crore in foreign exchange — but the price to the motorist is not lower: E20 sells at the same pump price as ordinary petrol despite ethanol delivering only a third of petrol's energy per litre. And crucially, the recent surge in sugar prices is *not* caused by ethanol diversion: only 30 lt of sugar went to ethanol against a production shortfall of 34.5 lt from the original estimate.
Impact for India
- Sugar mills: B-heavy molasses ethanol costs about ₹66/litre to make but sells at a fixed ₹60.73; Balrampur Chini's ethanol profit fell from ₹326 crore in 2023-24 to ₹192 crore the next year.
- Distilleries: Installed ethanol capacity is nearly 2,000 crore litres a year against annual demand of only 1,100-1,200 crore litres, leaving about 450 crore litres idle — running at roughly half capacity.
- Poultry and animal-feed industry: Competes with distilleries for maize; feed accounts for 60-70% of production cost, forcing imports from Myanmar and Ukraine.
- Maize farmers: Domestic maize prices rose from about ₹15,000 to ₹25,000 a tonne over four years as distilleries absorbed the crop.
- Sugar consumers: Retail sugar prices up ₹20/kg in a month; the government has banned sugar exports till September 30, allowed 10 lt of raw sugar imports at zero duty till October 31, and capped dealer stocks at 400 tonnes.
- Public finances: The Centre says blending has saved over ₹1 lakh crore in foreign exchange since inception.
Key data
Concepts
Theory lens
Administered pricing under a public procurement regime — when the government fixes both the input price (via a minimum support or fair remunerative price for the farmer) and the output price (via a fixed ethanol procurement rate for the mill), the residual claimant absorbs any adverse cost shock. In India's ethanol chain, sugarcane's fair-and-remunerative price has risen 16.5% since 2022 while B-heavy ethanol's procurement rate has stayed frozen at ₹60.73/litre against a production cost of about ₹66/litre. The mill absorbs the ₹5-and-change gap on every litre. The maize track shows the mirror problem: the government fixes ₹71.86/litre for maize ethanol, well above the current ~₹55/litre economic value of crude oil, so the exchequer effectively cross-subsidises maize farmers through the fuel bill.
Global context
Brazil, the country India cites as its ethanol model, runs the policy differently — ethanol prices are set by the market rather than administered, and Brazilian vehicles can run 85% or 100% ethanol blends, so drivers switch to ethanol only when it is cheap enough to offset the lower energy content per litre. In India, E20 sells at the same pump price as regular petrol despite ethanol's lower energy density, so consumers cannot arbitrage the two, and the flex-fuel vehicle stock is negligible.
Stakeholders
Practice Question — from the story
With reference to India's ethanol blending programme in 2025-26, consider the following statements:
- Sugarcane-based feedstocks contributed over 60% of the ethanol supplied to oil marketing companies for blending between November 2025 and July 2026.
- India remained a net exporter of maize in 2024 as domestic distillery demand did not require imports.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
Reveal answer & explanation
Answer: Neither 1 nor 2
- Statement 1: Incorrect. Sugarcane-based routes (direct juice/syrup, B-heavy and C-heavy molasses) supplied 259.24 crore litres — only 32% — of the 810.67 crore litres blended in Nov 2025-July 2026. Grain feedstock (maize, FCI rice, damaged foodgrains) contributed the remaining 68%.
- Statement 2: Incorrect. In 2024, India became a net importer of maize for the first time in decades, buying about 0.9 million tonnes worth ~$220 million from Myanmar and Ukraine.
Therefore, the correct answer is Neither 1 nor 2.
Concept check — test your understanding
Sugar mills producing ethanol from B-heavy molasses report that it costs about ₹66 a litre to make but sells at a government-fixed ₹60.73 a litre, while sugarcane's guaranteed grower price has been raised 16.5% since 2022. Which concept best captures the economic squeeze on the mill's ethanol business?
Reveal answer & explanation
Answer: D
- The output price (₹60.73/litre for B-heavy ethanol) is administered by the government and has been frozen since 2022, while the input cost driver — the fair-and-remunerative price of sugarcane, which the mill must pay growers — has risen 16.5%. That is a textbook administered-price margin squeeze: the residual claimant, the mill, absorbs the wedge.
- A: A price floor set below the clearing price is a contradiction in terms — a floor binds only when it is above the clearing price. The dynamic here is a price ceiling on the mill's realisation, not a floor.
- B: Cross-subsidisation runs from the sugar side to the ethanol side inside these mills, not the other way; sugar prices are what is holding many mills up while ethanol margins compress.
- C: A cobweb cycle involves oscillating quantities from lagged supply response to unregulated prices, not the squeeze between two administered prices moving in opposite directions.