With its carbon market live, India should join global coalition, economists argue
With its Carbon Credit Trading Scheme (CCTS) now live, India should join the coalition aligning the world's compliance carbon markets, argue Vaibhav Chaturvedi and Catherine Wolfram.
What happened
India should join the Open Coalition on Compliance Carbon Markets (OCCCM), argue Vaibhav Chaturvedi of the Council on Energy, Environment and Water (CEEW) and Catherine Wolfram of MIT Sloan. Their case starts from India's own market going live. On July 31, nearly 500 companies across seven industrial sectors filed their first compliance reports under the national Carbon Credit Trading Scheme (CCTS). The first credits are due in October, with trading on power exchanges expected between November and January. The European Union, China and Brazil launched the coalition in May; India has stayed outside.
Context
The CCTS, a compliance carbon market with binding targets and penalties, has been on paper since 2023 and is in its first phase. It is meant to deliver India's Nationally Determined Contribution (NDC) targets and the 2070 net-zero goal. The OCCCM, launched in Florence, is a forum for exchange on carbon pricing, on monitoring, reporting and verification (MRV) systems, on carbon accounting methods and on the use of high-integrity offsets. Germany and New Zealand joined first; Canada, France, Norway, Singapore, Türkiye and the United Kingdom followed. The coalition adopted its first work plan in Wuhan on September 14.
Why it matters
A carbon price puts a cost on each tonne of emissions, so the cheapest cuts happen first. The authors argue this minimises the economy-wide cost of cutting emissions, which matters for the global South, and can raise revenue when government budgets are stretched. Over 50 countries now price carbon, and the authors expect these systems to link, at least partly. Linking would let India earn revenue from jurisdictions with stricter targets. Their second reason is the EU's Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM), a tax on the carbon content of imports. A coalition built around such border taxes could set common or differentiated carbon prices and penalise non-members, so the authors argue the bigger risk is staying outside the room where the rules are written.
Impact for India
- Covered industry: nearly 500 companies in seven sectors now report under a scheme with binding targets and penalties, and will be able to trade credits on power exchanges from November to January.
- Exporters: the coalition's work on MRV, carbon accounting and domestic compliance markets is directly relevant to dealing with CBAM-style border taxes, the authors argue.
- Revenue: linking the CCTS to other carbon trading systems could earn India revenue from jurisdictions with more stringent mitigation targets.
- Policy autonomy: the coalition does not enforce mitigation targets, but members are likely to make critical decisions as talks evolve; Brazil being a founding member is a comfort for India, the authors write.
Key data
Concepts
Theory lens
Pigouvian pricing and least-cost abatement — a price on emissions makes polluters pay for the damage they impose on others, and trading lets the firms that can cut emissions most cheaply do more of the cutting. That is the basis for the authors' claim that a carbon price minimises the economy-wide cost of mitigation. Linking India's CCTS to markets with stricter targets would extend the same logic across borders, letting India earn revenue from jurisdictions where cutting emissions costs more.
Global context
The authors argue that climate coalitions are gaining ground as geopolitics fractures negotiations under the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) and attention shifts to implementation. The EU's CBAM is now operational and other countries are considering their own versions. The coalition's developing-country members, starting with Brazil, are the reason the authors think joining carries limited risk.
Stakeholders
Practice Question — from the story
With reference to India's Carbon Credit Trading Scheme (CCTS) and the Open Coalition on Compliance Carbon Markets (OCCCM), consider the following statements:
- On July 31, nearly 500 companies across seven industrial sectors filed their first compliance reports under the CCTS.
- The OCCCM was launched by the European Union, China and Brazil, and India has not yet joined it.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
Reveal answer & explanation
Answer: Both 1 and 2
- Statement 1: Correct because the first compliance reports under the CCTS were filed on July 31 by nearly 500 companies across seven industrial sectors.
- Statement 2: Correct because the EU, China and Brazil launched the OCCCM in May, and India has stayed outside so far.
Therefore, the correct answer is Both 1 and 2.
Concept check — test your understanding
Why does an emissions trading scheme cut a given amount of emissions at lower total cost than requiring every firm to cut by the same amount?
Reveal answer & explanation
Answer: B
- Trading moves the cutting to where it is cheapest until marginal abatement costs are equal across firms, which is why the authors say a carbon price minimises the economy-wide cost of mitigation.
- Option A is a real co-benefit the authors mention, fiscal revenue, but revenue does not lower the cost of the cuts themselves.
- Option C is a misconception: firms can and often do pass a carbon price on to consumers.
- Option D confuses cost with quantity: with the same target, trading changes who cuts and at what cost, not how much is cut.