Live on XaptiqUGC NET Economics (Dec 2026) and IIT JAM Economics (EN) test series are now live on Xaptiq.View test series
ExplainedLabour > MaritimeIndian EconomyHuman CapitalServices

Wages two to three times normal keep Indian crews sailing through Hormuz

Sixteen Indian seafarers have been killed since the West Asia conflict began in February. The shipping regulator says many accept conflict-zone work because the pay is two to three times what they would earn elsewhere.

What happened

Sixteen Indian seafarers have been killed in attacks on merchant ships since the West Asia conflict began in February, and thirty-three have been injured, with three missing. All but one of the dead were on foreign-flagged vessels. India has not barred its seafarers from the conflict zone. Shyam Jagannathan, Director General of Shipping, said some "continue to accept assignments in conflict zones because shipping companies offer two to three times their normal wages, while others may be driven by financial necessity". He added that foreign-flagged vessels have taken more hits, "however, in terms of casualties, India has paid the highest cost".

Context

The exposure follows from India's position in the global labour market for crew. India is the second-largest supplier of seafarers after the Philippines, and its workforce grew from 1.03 lakh in 2013 to 3.23 lakh in 2025. More than nine in 10 Indian seafarers in the fleets the government tracks serve on foreign-flagged vessels, which is why 15 of the 16 dead were on foreign ships. The Indian flag offers diplomatic protection, but most Indians at sea are not under it. The conflict began when the US and Israel struck Iran on February 28; Iran declared the Strait of Hormuz closed on March 4, and ceasefires in April and June both collapsed.

Why it matters

This is a wage premium doing the work that a ban would otherwise do, and it is a textbook compensating differential - extra pay demanded for worse conditions. The regulator issues advisories, not prohibitions. The one hard rule came on August 5: under Circular 47, a shipowner or crewing agency must inform the authorities before taking a vessel through Hormuz, and must obtain the written consent of every Indian seafarer on board. That converts an employment decision into an informed one without removing the choice, which matters when the alternative for some crew is financial necessity. Seafarers are now recognised as key workers under the Merchant Shipping Act, 2025, with a right to a safe workplace.

Impact for India

  • Seafarers: Conflict-zone assignments pay two to three times normal wages, and consent is now mandatory before a Hormuz transit under Circular 47.
  • Families of the dead: The Seafarers Welfare Fund Society pays Rs 10 lakh ex gratia for a death in a war-like or high-risk zone, with union members receiving a further Rs 10 lakh or Rs 12 lakh.
  • Shipping companies: Recruitment and Placement Service Licence agencies must verify a vessel's ownership, flag, insurance and certificates before signing on crew.
  • Trade routes: Before the war Hormuz carried 130 to 140 tankers a day; it is now 16 or 17, with the strait largely shut to commercial traffic.
  • Regulatory reach: Under DGS Order No. 08 of 2026, 366 foreign-flagged vessels with more than two recorded cases of abandoning seafarers are barred from hiring Indians through approved agencies.

Key data

Indian seafarers killed since February: 16Thirty-three injured, three missingAll but one on foreign-flagged vessels
Conflict-zone wage premium: Two to three times normal wagesAs stated by the Director General of Shipping
Indian seafarer workforce: 3.23 lakh in 2025Up from 1.03 lakh in 2013Second-largest supplier after the Philippines
Hormuz tanker traffic: 16 or 17 a dayDown from 130 to 140 before the warStrait largely shut to commercial traffic
Ex gratia for death in a high-risk zone: Rs 10 lakhFrom the Seafarers Welfare Fund SocietyPlus Rs 10 lakh or Rs 12 lakh for union members

Concepts

Compensating wage differentialThe additional pay a worker requires to accept a job with worse or riskier conditions, holding skill constant.Two to three times normal wages is what shipping companies pay to staff voyages through a conflict zone.
Flag of registrationThe state whose law a merchant ship sails under, which determines the diplomatic and regulatory protection the vessel carries.More than nine in 10 Indian seafarers serve on foreign-flagged ships, so the Indian flag's protection does not reach them.
Informed consent as regulationA rule that requires disclosure and agreement rather than prohibiting an activity outright, leaving the choice with the person exposed to the risk.Circular 47 requires written consent from every Indian seafarer before a Hormuz transit instead of banning the voyage.
Innocent passageThe right under the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea for ships to pass through another state's territorial waters without interference, provided they are not threatening.India's legal position rests on this right, alongside the safe-workplace protection in the Merchant Shipping Act, 2025.

Theory lens

Compensating wage differentials - in a labour market where workers can choose between jobs, those with worse conditions must pay more to attract anyone, so the premium measures the risk being transferred. The Director General of Shipping puts that premium at two to three times normal wages for conflict-zone voyages, while noting others are driven by financial necessity. Where workers have poor outside options, the premium understates the risk they bear, which is the case for mandating consent rather than relying on pay alone.

Global context

The risk is not confined to the Gulf. The Directorate General of Maritime Administration counts five Indian seafarer deaths in the Black Sea, where merchant ships have come under attack in the Russia-Ukraine war, along with eight injured and two missing. The Red Sea and the Gulf of Aden face separate threats from Houthi attacks and piracy, so Indian crews are exposed across three theatres at once.

Stakeholders

Gains: Seafarers taking conflict-zone workShipping companies offer two to three times normal wages for these assignments.
Gains: Crew on repatriationMore than 4,292 Indian seafarers have been flown home from the Gulf since the control room was activated.
Gains: Seafarers abandoned at seaWelfare Fund schemes pay Rs 20,000 a month for up to 12 months, and 366 repeat-offender vessels are barred from hiring Indians.
Pressure point: Indian crew on foreign-flagged shipsFifteen of the 16 dead were on foreign ships, which carry no Indian diplomatic protection.
Pressure point: Shipowners and charterersFreight costs have been driven to record highs by the disruption, with Hormuz traffic down to 16 or 17 tankers a day.
Pressure point: Crew on US-sanctioned vesselsIndia recognises only UN sanctions, so there is no Indian bar on crewing vessels the US has sanctioned - three Indians died when US forces struck the MT Settebello on June 9.

Practice Question — from the story

With reference to Indian seafarers and the regulation of conflict-zone voyages, consider the following statements:

  1. India is the largest supplier of seafarers in the world.
  2. Under DGS Order No. 08 of 2026, 366 foreign-flagged vessels are barred from entering Indian ports.

Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

  1. 1 only
  2. 2 only
  3. Both 1 and 2
  4. Neither 1 nor 2
Reveal answer & explanation

Answer: Neither 1 nor 2

  • Statement 1: Incorrect because India is the second-largest supplier of seafarers, after the Philippines, with a workforce of 3.23 lakh in 2025.
  • Statement 2: Incorrect because the 366 vessels, each with more than two recorded cases of abandoning seafarers, are barred from hiring Indians through approved agencies. The order restricts recruitment, not port entry.

Therefore, the correct answer is Neither 1 nor 2.

Concept check — test your understanding

Shipping companies pay two to three times normal wages to crew voyages through a conflict zone. What is such a premium called in labour economics?

  1. An efficiency wage, paid above the market rate to raise worker effort and reduce shirking.
  2. A compensating wage differential, the extra pay a worker requires to accept worse or riskier conditions.
  3. A reservation wage, the lowest pay at which a worker is willing to accept any employment at all.
  4. A monopsony rent, the surplus a single dominant employer extracts from workers with no alternative buyer.
Reveal answer & explanation

Answer: B

  • When two jobs demand the same skill but one carries greater risk, the riskier one must pay more to attract workers. That gap is a compensating differential, and the regulator's two-to-three-times figure is its size here.
  • Option A describes a premium paid to change how hard a worker works, not to offset job conditions; the hazard here is external to effort.
  • Option C defines the floor below which a worker will not work at all, which is a different concept from the gap between two jobs.
  • Option D is tempting because the article notes some seafarers are driven by financial necessity. But a monopsony rent is a surplus the employer captures, whereas this premium is paid out to the worker.