India's model BIT reset needs a proper consultation, not just a fresh text, argues Prabhash Ranjan
India is revising its 2015 model bilateral investment treaty and the revised text is set to go before the Union Cabinet; Prabhash Ranjan argues the substance needs a wider consultation to fix its "democratic deficit", not just a rewritten draft.
What happened
India is revising its model bilateral investment treaty (BIT) and the revised text will soon be placed before the Union Cabinet, writes Prabhash Ranjan of Jindal Global Law School. Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman had signalled the revamp in the Union Budget speech in 2025. The current model dates to 2015, adopted after India was hit by several investor claims; India also unilaterally terminated many earlier BITs and used the 2015 template as the basis for new negotiations. In the last decade or so, Ranjan notes, India has managed to conclude only a handful of BITs on the 2015 model, a track record he attributes to the text's tilt against investor protection.
Context
The 2015 model, Ranjan argues, is heavily tilted towards preserving the state's right to regulate at the cost of investment protection, which — combined with high regulatory risk and a slow judicial system — deters capital-exporting countries. Any review has two parts: what to change in the substance (arbitration access, protection standards, investment facilitation) and how to run the process. The second half has been under-discussed. Ranjan cites the UK and Australia (mandatory parliamentary tabling of negotiated treaties), Norway (two rounds of public consultation on model updates in 2008 and 2015), Colombia (public consultation on its model), and India's own March 2015 draft circulation, on which the Law Commission of India delivered its 260th report.
Why it matters
A model BIT sets the default terms on which foreign capital enters and disputes are resolved, so it directly shapes the risk premium capital-exporting countries price into Indian projects. If the reset again lands on a text that scares off arbitration-comfortable investors, India will keep signing few new BITs and keep facing legal challenges under the older ones. The deeper argument is procedural: economic treaties bind future governments and citizens for decades, so the "all-affected principle" says stakeholders — Parliament, experts, industry, arbitrators, civil society — should be able to weigh in before ratification, not after.
Impact for India
- Ministry of Finance / Ministry of External Affairs: Will steer the revised text through Cabinet; the political test is whether it strikes a middle ground between arbitration access for investors and protection of India's regulatory space.
- Foreign investors and their home states: Better arbitration access and clearer substantive protections would lower perceived expropriation and regulatory risk on Indian projects.
- Parliament and its committees: Ranjan's proposal to place the draft on the floor of Parliament and route it through department-related committees would be a departure from India's usual executive-led treaty practice.
- Law Commission of India, universities and think tanks: A structured external consultation — a Norway-2008/2015 style public consultation and a UK/Australia-style parliamentary tabling — could institutionalise expert scrutiny beyond the government's internal deliberations.
Key data
Concepts
Theory lens
All-affected principle — a democratic theory concept, associated with Robert Dahl and revived in EU legitimacy debates, that people substantially affected by a collective decision should have a genuine say in shaping it. Ranjan applies it to treaty-making: because BITs constrain domestic regulatory choices for decades and expose the state to arbitration risk, the executive alone signing them behind closed doors leaves an accountability gap that formal parliamentary tabling and public consultation help close.
Historical parallel
India's March 2015 circulation of the draft model BIT is itself the closest domestic precedent — the Law Commission of India, given that opportunity, assembled a team of experts and delivered its 260th report with detailed recommendations, though the final December 2015 text did not accept all of them. Ranjan reads this as an unfinished experiment worth repeating with wider reach.
Global context
Ranjan points to the UK and Australia, which mandatorily place negotiated treaty texts on the floor of Parliament before ratification, and to Norway, which held two rounds of public consultations on updates to its model BIT (in 2008 and 2015). Colombia likewise released its model BIT for public consultation, treating investment-treaty design as a matter for open democratic input rather than closed-door negotiation.
Stakeholders
Practice Question — from the story
With reference to India’s Model Bilateral Investment Treaty and the ongoing revision, consider the following statements:
- India last adopted its Model Bilateral Investment Treaty in 2008, and the Law Commission of India examined it in its 260th report.
- Union Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman signalled a revamp of the 2015 Model BIT in the Union Budget speech in 2025, and the revised text is set to be placed before the Union Cabinet.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
Reveal answer & explanation
Answer: 2 only
- Statement 1: Incorrect because India adopted its current Model BIT in December 2015 (not 2008). The Law Commission of India did examine the March 2015 draft and submitted the 260th report on it, but the model itself is a 2015 text.
- Statement 2: Correct because Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman said in her Union Budget speech in 2025 that India was considering revamping its 2015 Model BIT, and the revised text is soon to be placed before the Union Cabinet.
Therefore, the correct answer is 2 only.
Concept check — test your understanding
In an investment treaty, the phrase "the state’s right to regulate" primarily refers to:
Reveal answer & explanation
Answer: A
- The "right to regulate" is the doctrine that a state retains sovereign policy space to change its rules for legitimate public purposes; investment treaties either preserve or narrow that space depending on their protection standards. The op-ed argues India’s 2015 model tilts too far in preserving it, at the cost of investor protection.
- Option B confuses BIT rights (investor-vs-state) with WTO panel rights (state-vs-state), which are two distinct regimes.
- Option C describes a guaranteed-return promise, which BITs deliberately do not make — protection is against unfair treatment, not against commercial risk.
- Option D conflates a substantive regulatory issue (convertibility) with a forum choice (domestic courts), whereas the right-to-regulate debate is about whether the state acts, not where investors sue.