India shortens the local-remedies wait in its new investment treaties
India is rebuilding the bilateral investment treaty network it dismantled after 2016, with 4-5 agreements expected by year-end. The concession is on exhaustion of local remedies — how long an investor must pursue Indian courts before going to international arbitration — down from five years to three with the UAE and two with Saudi Arabia.
What happened
A decade after unilaterally terminating bilateral investment treaties, India has begun a significant overhaul of its treaty network, with expectations of 4-5 agreements being sealed by year-end. Following the 2025-26 Union Budget announcement of a review of the 2016 model treaty to make it more investor-friendly, Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman said the new template would be approved by the Cabinet "shortly". Agreements with Saudi Arabia, Israel and the UAE have already been signed with the new framework in mind. The treaty with Saudi Arabia, finalised last week, lets an investor approach international arbitration after two years.
Context
Before the 2016 model, India had signed investment treaties with 83 countries under a template dating from 1993 and amended in 2003, of which 74 were ratified. Notice of termination went to 68 of those countries with a request to renegotiate on the 2016 model, according to government data placed in Parliament in March 2023. Since then India has signed treaties with Belarus, the Kyrgyz Republic, the UAE and Uzbekistan, plus an investment cooperation and facilitation treaty with Brazil. India's insistence on a five-year wait before arbitration had been a major complaint from foreign investors.
Why it matters
A bilateral investment treaty is a commitment device. It attracts capital by promising an investor that the rules will not be changed against them, and it is enforced through investor-state dispute settlement, which lets a company sue a government directly. The exhaustion-of-local-remedies period is where the bargain is priced: a long wait keeps disputes in Indian courts and preserves room to regulate, while a short one buys credibility with capital. India has moved from five years to three with the UAE and two with Saudi Arabia, with partners pressing for one and India so far refusing. The Saudi agreement comes amid expectation of Saudi investment in Indian refineries, which shows what the concession is being traded for. Lawyers quoted in the reporting argue the shorter period only works if investor disputes are genuinely fast-tracked, and that this would need a statutory basis available to domestic and foreign investors alike, since Indian courts cannot give one litigant priority by nationality.
Impact for India
- Foreign investors: a two to three year wait before international arbitration instead of five, which materially shortens the path to an enforceable remedy.
- Policy space: a shorter wait moves disputes out of Indian courts sooner and into tribunals, which is the room to regulate that the 2016 reset was designed to protect.
- Sector pipeline: the Saudi treaty comes with expectation of Saudi investment in Indian refineries, the kind of long-lived, sunk-cost asset that treaty protection is most used to secure.
- Domestic litigants: lawyers argue that fast-tracking investor disputes requires a statutory mechanism open to all investors, because the judicial process cannot prefer one party on the basis of nationality.
Key data
Concepts
Theory lens
Commitment versus discretion — a host state can attract investment by binding itself not to change the rules after capital is sunk, but the same binding costs it the freedom to regulate later in the public interest. The exhaustion-of-local-remedies period is where that trade-off is set numerically. India's move from five years to two with Saudi Arabia buys credibility with investors by giving up time it had reserved for its own courts.
Historical parallel
India was not alone in retreating from these treaties. South Africa and Indonesia also terminated theirs to preserve policy space, after a run of adverse international tribunal decisions that developing states read as encroaching on domestic policy. India's own termination notices went to 68 countries with a request to renegotiate on the 2016 model, and the current round is the renegotiation finally happening — on terms closer to what investors asked for.
Global context
Richer economies have been moving the other way on arbitration. The European Union has withdrawn from the Energy Charter Treaty on the view that its dispute settlement is incompatible with the Paris Agreement, the United States and Canada removed investor-state dispute settlement from the USMCA, and New Zealand opted out of those provisions in the CPTPP. India is loosening its local-remedies rule just as several advanced economies are abandoning the arbitration route altogether.
Stakeholders
Practice Question — from the story
With reference to India's bilateral investment treaties, consider the following statements:
- Under the treaty finalised with Saudi Arabia, an investor may approach international arbitration after two years of pursuing local remedies.
- India had signed investment treaties with 83 countries under the 2016 model treaty, of which 74 were ratified.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
Reveal answer & explanation
Answer: 1 only
- Statement 1: Correct because the Saudi Arabia agreement sets a two-year exhaustion of local remedies period, against three years in the treaty with the UAE and the five years India had insisted on after the earlier terminations.
- Statement 2: Incorrect because the 83 countries and 74 ratifications relate to the model treaty of 1993 as amended in 2003; the 2016 model is what India issued termination notices in order to renegotiate on, to 68 of those countries.
Therefore, the correct answer is 1 only.
Concept check — test your understanding
What is a host state giving up when it shortens the exhaustion-of-local-remedies period in an investment treaty?
Reveal answer & explanation
Answer: B
- The exhaustion requirement reserves a period of domestic judicial primacy. Cutting it from five years to two moves disputes into investor-state arbitration sooner, which is exactly the policy space the earlier terminations were meant to protect.
- Option A is unaffected by the remedies clause; taxing rights are negotiated separately.
- Option C is a real and much-discussed sovereign power, but entry screening is a different instrument from dispute settlement.
- Option D is a genuine concern researchers raise about this treaty architecture more broadly, and the article cites it — but it is a constraint the treaties impose generally, not something the remedies period itself governs.