Live on XaptiqUGC NET Economics (Dec 2026) and IIT JAM Economics (EN) test series are now live on Xaptiq.View test series
NationalCentre State RelationsPublic FinanceFiscal FederalismMineral Taxation

Parliament passes MMDR amendment; Jharkhand's Soren cries fiscal foul

Parliament has cleared the Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Amendment Bill, 2026, which bars states from taxing mineral rights and mineral-bearing lands beyond a Centre-prescribed ceiling. Jharkhand CM Hemant Soren, whose state accounts for about 40% of India's minerals, has asked the Prime Minister to reconsider.

What happened

Both Houses cleared the Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Amendment Bill, 2026 by Thursday, August 13. The Bill prohibits states from imposing specified levies on mineral rights and mineral-bearing lands except in accordance with conditions or restrictions prescribed by the Centre. It also extinguishes any unpaid or unrecovered dues from such levies imposed before the amendment commences, though levies already paid or recovered will not be refunded. Union Mines Minister G. Kishan Reddy said the change applies only to major minerals — coal, iron ore, bauxite, manganese, copper and others — and would affect around 11 mineral-producing states. Minor minerals such as sand, gravel, ordinary clay and building stone remain fully with the states.

Context

The amendment lands after the Supreme Court's nine-judge Constitution Bench held in July 2024 that states have legislative competence to tax mineral-bearing lands under Entry 49 of the State List, and allowed states to recover tax arrears from April 1, 2005 without interest or penalty. Reddy argued the objective is uniformity in major-mineral prices, so that coal or iron-ore cost differentials do not push firms to arbitrage across states or pull imports upward when domestic coal grades are lower. He said states' share in overall mineral revenues rose from 65% to 88% between 2014-15 and 2024-25, and that mineral revenue for states climbed from Rs 13,258 crore to Rs 71,035 crore over the same window.

Why it matters

The core question is fiscal federalism: who gets the tax handle on a natural resource that sits inside a state but feeds a national market? A blanket ceiling under Union rules on state levies moves the balance toward the Centre in a domain the Supreme Court had recently affirmed as state territory. For resource-rich states, mineral levies are not marginal revenue — Jharkhand CM Hemant Soren said mining revenue accounted for 84.9% of the state's own non-tax revenue in 2024-25 and that the state-designed Mineral Bearing Land Cess was expected to generate around Rs 7,110 crore annually. The trade-off is the input-price channel the Centre invokes: variable state levies feed into cement, steel and infrastructure costs and into headline inflation.

Impact for India

  • Resource-rich states (Jharkhand, Odisha, Chhattisgarh, Karnataka and others): Direct revenue risk on state levies over and above royalty and District Mineral Foundation contributions; Soren has warned the Mukhyamantri Maiyaa Samman Yojana, Abua Awas Yojana, pensions and rural infrastructure spending in mining-affected districts could be squeezed.
  • Mineral-using industries (steel, cement, power): The Centre expects greater price uniformity for major minerals across states, which Reddy said would soften pass-through into cement and steel prices and infrastructure costs.
  • Public Sector Undertakings operating mines in resource-rich states: Soren pressed the point that PSUs extract significant value from state resources and that a reasonable share should stay with the state.
  • Fiscal federalism architecture: The Bill effectively overrides the July 2024 nine-judge Constitution Bench ruling that recognised states' power to tax under Entry 49; Soren has flagged constitutional and legal remedies including the Supreme Court, and asked for a GST Council-style structured consultation with mineral-producing states.
  • Coal and minerals exchange: Reddy said the amendment paves the way for a coal and minerals exchange, with India's first coal exchange expected in eight to nine months — reforms that need uniform prices to trade cleanly.

Key data

Jharkhand share of India's minerals: About 40%
Mining revenue as share of Jharkhand's own non-tax revenue (2024-25): 84.9%State Economic Survey for 2025-26
Projected annual yield of Jharkhand Mineral Bearing Land Cess: Around Rs 7,110 crore
States' share in mineral revenues: 88% in 2024-25Up from 65% in 2014-15Central government's share fell from 35% to 12%
States' mineral revenue (aggregate): Rs 71,035 crore in 2024-25Vs Rs 13,258 crore in 2014-15
States affected by the amendment: Around 11 mineral-producing states

Concepts

Major vs minor mineralsUnder the MMDR Act, major minerals (coal, iron ore, bauxite, manganese, copper and similar) are regulated by the Centre; minor minerals (sand, gravel, ordinary clay, building stone) are regulated by states.The amendment applies only to major minerals; state control over minor minerals — including their taxation and cess — is untouched.
Entry 49 of the State ListThe constitutional entry that gives states the power to levy taxes on lands and buildings, including — as the Supreme Court held in July 2024 — mineral-bearing lands.Soren argues the Centre's proposed 'regulation' of mineral-bearing lands intrudes into a field the nine-judge Constitution Bench recognised as belonging to the states.
Own non-tax revenueRevenue a state raises on its own account outside taxation — royalties, cess on natural resources, dividends from state undertakings, user charges — as distinct from tax revenue or central transfers.Mining revenue was 84.9% of Jharkhand's own non-tax revenue in 2024-25, so a ceiling on state levies bites directly into a resource-rich state's fiscal room.
District Mineral FoundationA statutory body in each mineral-mining district funded by a percentage of the royalty from lease-holders, meant for the welfare of communities affected by mining.Soren cited DMF contributions alongside royalty and other statutory receipts as the fiscal base for roads, water, healthcare and rehabilitation in mining-affected areas.

Theory lens

Fiscal federalism assignment principle — Musgrave and Oates argue that taxation of a mobile base (labour, capital, tradable inputs) is best assigned to the higher tier of government to avoid harmful tax competition, while immobile bases (land, buildings) belong to sub-national governments. Mineral-bearing land is immobile, which is why the Supreme Court's 2024 ruling put it in Entry 49 of the State List. The MMDR amendment tests this by treating the price of extracted mineral, which is nationally tradable, as the object of concern — and using that channel to place a Union-imposed ceiling on state levies.

Stakeholders

Gains: Central government's price-uniformity agendaCeiling on state levies is expected to compress cross-state variation in major-mineral prices.
Gains: Mineral-using industries (steel, cement, power)More uniform input prices reduce the risk of state-by-state arbitrage in inputs like coal, limestone and iron ore.
Gains: Proposed coal and minerals exchangePrice uniformity is a precondition for a functioning centralised exchange, which the Centre wants operational in eight to nine months.
Pressure point: Jharkhand and other resource-rich statesDirect hit to own non-tax revenue; Jharkhand's Mineral Bearing Land Cess alone was projected at around Rs 7,110 crore a year.
Pressure point: State-financed welfare and rehabilitation in mining districtsSoren has flagged risk to schemes like Maiya Samman Yojana, Abua Awas Yojana and pensions if state levies are compressed.

Practice Question — from the story

With reference to the Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Amendment Bill, 2026, consider the following statements:

  1. The amendment ends the distinction between major and minor minerals under the MMDR Act, bringing both categories under Union regulation.
  2. It repeals the July 2024 Supreme Court judgment that had allowed states to tax mineral rights and mineral-bearing lands.

Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

  1. 1 only
  2. 2 only
  3. Both 1 and 2
  4. Neither 1 nor 2
Reveal answer & explanation

Answer: Neither 1 nor 2

  • Statement 1: Incorrect. Union Minister G. Kishan Reddy explicitly said the amendment covers only major minerals — coal, iron ore, bauxite, manganese, copper and similar — and that states retain absolute control over minor minerals like sand, gravel, ordinary clay and building stone.
  • Statement 2: Incorrect. Parliament does not repeal a Supreme Court judgment; the July 2024 nine-judge Constitution Bench held that states have legislative competence to tax mineral-bearing lands under Entry 49 of the State List. The amendment instead restricts state levies by prescribing Centre-set conditions, which is why Jharkhand CM Hemant Soren has reserved the right to move the Supreme Court against the Bill.

Therefore, the correct answer is Neither 1 nor 2.

Concept check — test your understanding

In fiscal federalism, why is the taxation of mineral-bearing land traditionally considered a natural fit for the sub-national (state) level rather than the central government?

  1. Land is an immobile tax base, so state-level rate variation cannot cause the base to move across borders in the way capital or labour can.
  2. State-level land taxes fall entirely on non-residents, so they satisfy the benefit principle of taxation without political cost to the state.
  3. The Constitution requires that any tax on a natural resource be shared equally between the state where it is located and the Centre.
  4. Mineral extraction generates only local externalities, so central taxation would violate the polluter-pays principle.
Reveal answer & explanation

Answer: A

  • Musgrave-Oates-style tax assignment says mobile bases (capital, tradable inputs, skilled labour) belong to the higher tier of government because otherwise sub-national tax competition erodes the base; immobile bases (land and buildings) belong to sub-national governments because they cannot relocate in response to a rate change. Mineral-bearing land is immobile, which is exactly why Entry 49 of the State List assigns the tax on lands and buildings to the states and why the July 2024 Supreme Court ruling recognised state competence over mineral-bearing land.
  • Option B is a common misconception — a state land tax is largely borne by domestic producers and consumers, not by non-residents.
  • Option C is not a constitutional rule; Centre-collected taxes are shared by Finance Commission awards, not by a mineral-specific equal split.
  • Option D flips the polluter-pays logic — the local externalities of mining (displacement, environmental costs) are precisely why states argue they must retain a revenue handle to fund rehabilitation.