Live on XaptiqUGC NET Economics (Dec 2026) and IIT JAM Economics (EN) test series are now live on Xaptiq.View test series
NationalFiscal FederalismPublic FinanceTaxationState Finances

Odisha yet to quantify revenue hit from mines Act Section 9D

Odisha's government told the Assembly it has made no estimate of the revenue it loses under Section 9D of the amended mines Act, which bars State levies on mineral rights without Union approval.

What happened

The Odisha Assembly on Thursday took up 13 written questions on what the Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Amendment Act, 2026 costs the State exchequer. Legislators across party lines focused on Section 9D, which stops State governments from placing independent taxes or cesses on mineral rights or mineral-bearing lands without the Union government's approval. Steel and Mines Minister Bibhuti Bhusan Jena replied that no quantified assessment has been done. "No specific estimate of financial gain or loss has been made at this stage," he said, adding that the State will assess the impact once the Centre frames rules.

Context

Parliament's recent amendments curbed the power of State governments to impose taxes, cess and other levies on mineral rights and mineral-bearing lands. The question is live in Odisha because the State's Advocate General had argued in the Supreme Court in favour of levying on mineral-bearing lands. The Minister said figures published in the Odisha Review or placed before the Supreme Court are not being treated as a departmental assessment of Section 9D's impact. Chief Minister Mohan Majhi and former Union Education Minister Dharmendra Pradhan had earlier dismissed concerns about a loss to the exchequer.

Why it matters

This is a fiscal federalism question with a revenue number attached. Mineral-rich States raise a large share of their own tax revenue from levies on mining, so a Union restriction on that power shifts the vertical balance between what a State spends and what it can raise itself. The gap must then be filled by transfers the State does not control. The Minister's answer also shows a second problem: a State cannot bargain over a revenue loss it has not measured, and the measurement is being deferred until the Centre writes the rules.

Impact for India

  • Odisha's exchequer: the BJD and INDIA bloc parties put the loss at over ₹1 lakh crore in tax arrears and ₹12,000 crore a year; the State government has published no counter-estimate.
  • Mineral-rich States generally: Section 9D applies to all of them, so the precedent extends well beyond Odisha.
  • Union government: gains an approval gate over State levies on mineral rights and mineral-bearing lands.
  • Mining companies: face a more predictable levy regime with fewer independent State charges.
  • State budgeting: without a quantified estimate, Odisha cannot provision for the change in its own revenue forecasts.

Key data

Written questions tabled in the Odisha Assembly: 13
Annual revenue loss claimed by BJD and INDIA bloc: ₹12,000 crore
Tax arrears at stake, per opposition parties: Over ₹1 lakh crore
Odisha's share of India's mineral resources, per BJD: 44%

Concepts

CessA levy imposed for a specific purpose, collected over and above the base tax on the same item.Section 9D bars States from placing independent cesses on mineral rights without Union approval.
Fiscal federalismThe division of taxing powers and spending responsibilities between the Union and the States.The amendment moves a taxing power on minerals from the State side towards the Union side.
Vertical fiscal imbalanceThe gap between what a level of government must spend and what it can raise from its own taxes.Removing a State's mineral levy widens this gap and raises its reliance on Union transfers.
Own tax revenueThe tax a State collects under its own powers, as distinct from its share of Union taxes and grants.Mineral levies are a major own tax source for mineral-rich States like Odisha.

Theory lens

Fiscal federalism — the standard framework asks which level of government should tax what, balancing efficiency against the autonomy of sub-national units. Taxes on an immobile base such as mineral-bearing land are usually assigned to the level closest to it, because the base cannot flee the jurisdiction. Section 9D moves in the other direction: it keeps the base in the State but makes the levy conditional on Union approval, widening Odisha's vertical fiscal imbalance.

Stakeholders

Gains: Union governmentSection 9D makes State taxes and cesses on mineral rights conditional on Union approval.
Gains: Mining companiesFewer independent State levies on mineral rights and mineral-bearing lands.
Pressure point: Odisha's State exchequerOpposition parties estimate over ₹1 lakh crore in tax arrears and ₹12,000 crore in annual revenue at stake.
Pressure point: Mineral-bearing StatesLose an independent tax handle on a resource located within their territory.

Practice Question — from the story

With reference to Section 9D of the Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Amendment Act, 2026, consider the following statements:

  1. The Odisha government has placed a quantified estimate of the revenue loss from Section 9D before the State Assembly.
  2. Section 9D bars State governments from imposing independent taxes or cesses on mineral rights or mineral-bearing lands without the Union government's approval.

Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

  1. 1 only
  2. 2 only
  3. Both 1 and 2
  4. Neither 1 nor 2
Reveal answer & explanation

Answer: 2 only

  • Statement 1: Incorrect. Steel and Mines Minister Bibhuti Bhusan Jena told the Assembly that no quantified assessment has been made, saying no specific estimate of financial gain or loss exists at this stage. The State said it will assess the impact only after the Centre frames rules.
  • Statement 2: Correct. Section 9D stops State governments from placing independent taxes or cesses on mineral rights or mineral-bearing lands without the Union government's approval.

Therefore, the correct answer is 2 only.

Concept check — test your understanding

In fiscal federalism, what happens to a State's fiscal position when the Union restricts the State's power to levy its own tax on a resource located within that State?

  1. Its revenue falls but its fiscal autonomy is unchanged, because autonomy is determined by how freely a State can allocate its expenditure.
  2. There is no fiscal consequence so long as the State keeps receiving its share of Union tax devolution recommended by the Finance Commission.
  3. Its vertical fiscal imbalance widens, because a larger share of the State's spending must now be financed by transfers it does not control.
  4. The State can fully offset the loss by charging user fees on the same resource, since user charges fall outside the definition of a tax.
Reveal answer & explanation

Answer: C

  • Vertical fiscal imbalance is the gap between what a level of government must spend and what it can raise from its own taxes. Removing an own tax handle without changing spending duties widens that gap and pushes the State towards transfer financing, which it cannot set or predict.
  • Option A separates revenue from autonomy, but fiscal autonomy has a revenue side as well as a spending side; losing the power to set your own tax is a direct loss of autonomy.
  • Option B is a common misconception. Devolution is a share of Union taxes determined by a formula the State does not control, so it is not a substitute for an own tax the State can set itself.
  • Option D points to a genuine distinction between taxes and user charges, but user charges are tied to a service provided and cannot generally be scaled up to replace a broad levy on mineral rights.