India produces more milk but not enough milk fat
Butter prices rose over 54% between October 2023 and October 2026, against 18% for skimmed milk powder (SMP), as demand for ghee, paneer and butter outruns fat supply. Buffaloes, whose milk is richer in fat, now give about 45% of India's milk against 60% three decades ago. Mother Dairy has raised milk prices by ₹2-4 a litre.
What happened
India faces a shortage of milk fat even though milk output keeps growing, an Indian Express editorial argues. Average ex-dairy prices of butter rose over 54% between October 2023 and October 2026, against just 18% for skimmed milk powder (SMP). Milk production has grown about 3% a year over the past decade, but more of it now comes from cows than from buffaloes. Separately, Mother Dairy, the largest milk supplier in Delhi-NCR, raised consumer milk prices by ₹2-4 a litre from November 12, citing higher procurement prices paid to farmers. Full cream milk now costs ₹76 a litre, up from ₹72, and toned milk ₹62, up from ₹60.
Context
Standard cow milk has 3.5% fat and 8.5% solids-not-fat (SNF). Buffalo milk is taken at 6.5% fat and 9% SNF. Buffaloes now contribute hardly 45% of national milk output, against 60% three decades ago, so the same volume of milk carries less fat. Demand for fat has risen at the same time. Crackdowns by the Food Safety and Standards Authority of India (FSSAI) on ghee mixed with palm and other vegetable oils, especially after the Tirupati laddu scandal in September 2024, raised demand for genuine ghee, khoya and paneer. The GST cuts of September 2025 added to it: the rate on ghee, butter and cheese was cut from 12 to 5%, on ice-cream from 18 to 5%, and on paneer from 5% to nil. Mother Dairy last raised milk prices on May 14, 2026, and passes 75-80% of its milk sales realisation to farmers.
Why it matters
The shortage is a problem of composition, not quantity. Every litre of milk gives both fat and SNF, in proportions set by the animal. As the herd shifts towards cows, whose milk has less fat, meeting the rising demand for fat means processing more milk. That also produces more SNF, mostly as SMP, whose domestic market is not growing as fast. India could end up with surplus SMP and a deficit in fat, and the gap between butter prices, up over 54%, and SMP prices, up 18%, shows this has started. It also feeds into food inflation. Dairies pay farmers on the fat and SNF in their milk, so scarce fat raises procurement prices. Mother Dairy has now raised retail milk prices for the second time this year, and milk carries a large weight in the consumer price index. Policy has so far focused on total milk output, where India is the world's top producer. The editorial argues it now needs to address the supply of fat as well.
Impact for India
- Food inflation: Mother Dairy's rise of ₹2-4 a litre and costlier butter and ghee add to retail food prices.
- Dairy farmers: higher procurement prices raise incomes, most for those with buffaloes, whose milk carries more fat.
- Dairy trade: a surplus of SMP alongside a fat deficit could push dairies to export milk powder while fat stays scarce at home.
- Food safety: costlier genuine fat raises the reward for adulterating ghee, so FSSAI enforcement matters more.
Key data
Concepts
Theory lens
Joint supply — Alfred Marshall's example was wool and mutton from the same sheep. When two goods come from one process in fixed proportions, their prices cannot move independently. A rise in demand for one raises its price and calls forth more output of the process, which adds supply of the other good and pushes its price down. Milk works the same way: fat and SNF come together, in proportions set by the animal. Stronger demand for ghee and paneer raises the price of fat, and processing more milk to get it adds to stocks of SMP. A shift in the herd towards cows tightens the constraint, because each litre now carries less fat. The adjustment then comes through relative prices, butter rising far faster than SMP, until breeding, feeding or trade restore balance.
Stakeholders
Practice Question — from the story
With reference to milk production in India, consider the following statements:
- Buffalo milk has a higher fat content than standard cow milk.
- The share of buffaloes in India's milk output has risen over the past three decades.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
Reveal answer & explanation
Answer: 1 only
- Statement 1: Correct. Buffalo milk is taken at 6.5% fat, against 3.5% for standard cow milk.
- Statement 2: Incorrect. Buffaloes now contribute about 45% of milk output, down from 60% three decades ago; more milk now comes from cows.
Therefore, the correct answer is 1 only.
Concept check — test your understanding
Milk fat and skimmed milk powder (SMP) are joint products of raw milk. If demand for milk fat rises sharply while demand for SMP stays flat, what is the likely result?
Reveal answer & explanation
Answer: A
- Joint products are made together, so more fat means more SNF; with flat SMP demand, SMP prices lag, as with butter up over 54% against SMP up 18%.
- Coming from the same milk does not tie the two prices together; each depends on its own demand.
- SNF's larger share of milk solids means extra processing adds more SMP, which pushes its price down, not up.
- Fat and SNF come out of milk in fixed proportions set by the animal, so dairies cannot raise fat output alone.