Slower tax growth and rising subsidies put deficit target at risk
Halfway through this financial year, the Union government's gross tax collections have grown just 6.1%, excise revenue has fallen after fuel duty cuts, and the fertiliser subsidy looks set to overshoot. Capital spending has slowed sharply, and the fiscal deficit could exceed its 4.3% of GDP target.
What happened
Halfway through this financial year, the Union government's accounts point to a risk of missing the fiscal deficit target, argues an Indian Express editorial. Controller General of Accounts (CGA) data show gross tax collections grew 6.1% in April-September, slightly slower than the full-year growth assumed in the Budget. Excise revenue is the main drag. After the duty cuts on petrol and diesel, it was ₹1.07 lakh crore so far this year, against ₹1.38 lakh crore in the same period last year. On the spending side, capital expenditure grew 23.7% in the first quarter but only 2.8% in the second. The fertiliser subsidy is likely to exceed its budget.
Context
Some revenue items are doing better. Direct taxes have grown at a fairly healthy pace, with corporate tax growing faster than personal income tax. Customs collections grew 16.5% in the first half, according to rating agency ICRA, which could partly offset the excise shortfall. Disinvestment is also ahead of plan. The government has raised ₹55,757 crore from stake sales and another ₹6,366 crore from asset monetisation. With its share of the IDBI Bank sale, in which Fairfax Financial Holdings is buying a 60.72% stake for ₹52,878 crore, the ₹80,000 crore target is likely to be exceeded. The pressure is on spending. CareEdge Ratings expects the fertiliser subsidy to rise to ₹2.5-2.7 trillion, against ₹1.7 trillion in the Budget.
Why it matters
The Budget set the fiscal deficit at 4.3% of GDP. CareEdge now expects 4.3-4.5%. SBI economists expect the deficit to be ₹1.2 lakh crore higher than budgeted, because of the revenue lost to the excise cuts and higher fertiliser and petroleum and LPG subsidies. Stake-sale money can fill only part of that gap. The likely response is expenditure rationalisation in the coming months, the editorial says. That matters for the quality of the adjustment, not just its size. Capital spending has already slowed to 2.8% growth in the second quarter, while subsidies, which are revenue spending, are rising. If the deficit target is held by squeezing capital spending further, the fiscal numbers would look better but the economy would lose investment that supports growth. The excise cuts and higher subsidies also show the fiscal cost of shielding consumers and farmers from high oil and gas prices.
Impact for India
- Fiscal deficit: the 4.3% of GDP target could slip to 4.3-4.5%, with SBI estimating an extra ₹1.2 lakh crore of deficit.
- Public investment: capital expenditure growth fell from 23.7% in the first quarter to 2.8% in the second; further cuts to meet the target would hurt infrastructure spending.
- Fuel taxes: excise revenue fell to ₹1.07 lakh crore from ₹1.38 lakh crore after the petrol and diesel duty cuts.
- Fertiliser subsidy: a likely ₹2.5-2.7 trillion bill against ₹1.7 trillion budgeted adds to spending pressure.
- Borrowing: a wider deficit means more government borrowing, which can push up bond yields.
Key data
Concepts
Theory lens
Quality of fiscal adjustment — how a government meets a deficit target matters as much as whether it meets it. Capital spending tends to raise future output through better infrastructure and by drawing in private investment, so its multiplier is usually larger and longer-lasting than that of subsidies and other revenue spending. When revenue falls short mid-year, cutting capital spending is often the easiest way to hold the deficit, because subsidies and salaries are hard to cut. This year's numbers show this pattern starting: capital spending growth has slowed sharply while the subsidy bill rises. Holding the 4.3% target that way would protect the headline number at some cost to growth.
Stakeholders
Practice Question — from the story
With reference to the Union government's finances in the first half of this financial year, consider the following statements:
- Growth in the Centre's capital expenditure slowed in the second quarter compared with the first quarter.
- Customs duty collections fell in the first half because of the excise duty cuts on petrol and diesel.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
Reveal answer & explanation
Answer: 1 only
- Statement 1: Correct. Capital expenditure grew 23.7% in the first quarter but only 2.8% in the second.
- Statement 2: Incorrect. It was excise revenue that fell, to ₹1.07 lakh crore from ₹1.38 lakh crore. Customs collections grew 16.5% in the first half, according to ICRA, partly offsetting the excise shortfall.
Therefore, the correct answer is 1 only.
Concept check — test your understanding
When a government faces fiscal slippage in the middle of a year, why is cutting capital expenditure to hold the deficit target considered costly for growth?
Reveal answer & explanation
Answer: A
- Capital spending builds assets and draws in private investment, so a rupee cut from it usually costs more growth than a rupee cut from subsidies.
- Capital expenditure is not part of the revenue deficit, which covers only revenue receipts and revenue spending; cutting capex does not worsen it.
- All spending is financed from the same pool of receipts and borrowing; cutting capex lowers borrowing needs and so does not raise the interest bill.
- A capex cut can lower GDP somewhat, but in the same year the saving normally outweighs the effect on GDP, so the deficit ratio still falls; the cost shows up mainly in lost future growth.