Capital controls, not rule tweaks, hold back FDI, argues XKDR's Niharika Yadav
India's net foreign direct investment (FDI) fell from $40 billion in FY2021 to almost zero in FY2025, and only a rewrite of the foreign exchange law can change that, argues Niharika Yadav of the XKDR Forum.
What happened
The RBI's draft Foreign Investment Rules (FI Rules) tidy up procedure but leave untouched the real barrier to foreign capital, the Foreign Exchange Management Act (FEMA), argues Niharika Yadav, research lead at the XKDR Forum. Net FDI in India fell from $40 billion in FY2021 to effectively zero in FY2025. She credits the draft with shorter sections, an investee-centred framework and common definitions. But under Section 6 of FEMA, capital account transactions are banned unless the RBI or the government permits them. So the draft rules are only a schedule of exceptions to a default of restriction.
Context
India controls capital flows sector by sector. Foreign capital is barred in real estate business and capped in digital media, broadcasting, multi-brand retail and pensions. Yadav notes that no OECD country keeps general capital and exchange controls, and that Chile and Mexico avoid transaction-by-transaction regulation. Even in fully open sectors, the state prescribes the instrument, the recipient's legal form and the price. Transfers of unlisted shares between residents and non-residents need certified valuations first, and the draft narrows this latitude further. Expert committees led by Tarapore, Percy Mistry and U K Sinha, and the Financial Sector Legislative Reforms Commission (FSLRC), have already done much of the redesign work.
Why it matters
The argument is about the legal default. When every capital transaction is banned unless allowed, each new rule is an exception, and investors bear the cost of checking where they fall. Yadav proposes three principles. First, curbs on capital flows should be temporary emergency tools with stated aims; national security screening should sit with a body that weighs security against the cost of lost capital. She says Press Note 3, which restricts investment by nationality, should not have been issued by the Department for Promotion of Industry and Internal Trade (DPIIT) alone, since its job is to promote investment. Second, rules should go through public consultation, cost-benefit analysis and review, with national treatment for foreign investors once entry conditions are met. Third, controls should be neutral about the route and the investor, and each should be tied to an identified market failure. On pricing rules, she argues tax evasion should be handled after a transaction, not by fixing prices in advance.
Impact for India
- Foreign investors: mandated valuations and instrument rules add friction even in open sectors.
- RBI and the Finance Ministry: the draft FI Rules are a chance to simplify, but the author says a FEMA overhaul is needed.
- DPIIT: Press Note 3 shows how one department with a promotion mandate can also restrict investment.
- Indian firms seeking capital: costs of restriction appear slowly, as investments not made and firms not built.
Key data
Concepts
Theory lens
Capital mobility and the impossible trinity — an economy cannot have a fixed exchange rate, free capital movement and an independent monetary policy all at once, so countries that manage their currency often keep some capital controls. Yadav's argument is narrower. She accepts curbs as emergency tools for macroeconomic risk, but says India's controls are a permanent default applied transaction by transaction, which raises the cost of every investment rather than managing a specific risk.
Global context
No OECD country maintains general capital and exchange controls, according to the author, which makes India an outlier alongside China. Emerging economies such as Chile and Mexico have avoided transaction-by-transaction regulation of the capital account. For screening investment on national security grounds, she points to the US Committee on Foreign Investment in the United States (CFIUS) and the UK's Investment Security Unit as models that weigh security risks against the cost of restricting capital.
Stakeholders
Practice Question — from the story
With reference to India's foreign exchange law and the draft Foreign Investment Rules, consider the following statements:
- Under Section 6 of the Foreign Exchange Management Act, capital account transactions are prohibited unless specifically permitted by the RBI or the government.
- Transfers of unlisted shares between residents and non-residents require certified valuations before the transaction.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
Reveal answer & explanation
Answer: Both 1 and 2
- Statement 1: Correct. Section 6 of FEMA makes restriction the default, so the draft FI Rules work as a schedule of exceptions.
- Statement 2: Correct. Certified valuations are required before such transfers, and the draft rules narrow the latitude further.
Therefore, the correct answer is Both 1 and 2.
Concept check — test your understanding
In investment law, what is the main difference between a 'negative list' approach and a regime where capital account transactions are prohibited unless specifically permitted?
Reveal answer & explanation
Answer: B
- The two regimes differ in their default: a negative list names only what is restricted, while a permission-based regime such as Section 6 of FEMA bars everything not explicitly allowed.
- Sectoral caps can exist under either regime; they do not define the difference.
- Both approaches can cover portfolio and direct investment.
- Neither approach is about setting the exchange rate for individual transactions.