Live on XaptiqUGC NET Economics (Dec 2026) and IIT JAM Economics (EN) test series are now live on Xaptiq.View test series
OpinionDisaster Finance > InsurancePublic FinancePublic ExpenditureAgriculture

India has cut cyclone deaths but not cyclone losses, argues Purnadev Jena

India has cut cyclone deaths by 99.8% since 1999 but not the economic damage, and coastal States should pool risk through parametric insurance that pays out within days, argues economist Purnadev Jena.

What happened

India has engineered away cyclone deaths but left the economic losses untouched, argues Purnadev Jena, economic adviser in the Uttarakhand Chief Minister's office. Mortality from storms of similar force has fallen 99.8% since the 1999 Odisha super cyclone, which officially killed 9,885 people. As Cyclone Arnab hit the east coast, Andhra Pradesh put its preliminary loss at ₹4,600 crore. Jena proposes parametric insurance, with Odisha, Andhra Pradesh and West Bengal jointly financing a risk pool.

Context

The fall in deaths is a public-administration success. Cyclone Phailin in 2013 killed 21 people after 11.5 lakh were evacuated, Fani in 2019 killed 64 and Dana in 2024 six. Between 2014 and 2025, twelve major cyclones killed 147 people in all. This was built through the National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP), which spent Rs 4,331.68 crore over about 13 years. For Cyclone Arnab, Andhra Pradesh reported seven deaths, and a Central team is due to assess the damage.

Why it matters

The money losses dwarf the spending on prevention. Cyclone Amphan cost West Bengal Rs 1 lakh crore, equal to 61% of its budgeted revenue receipts for the year. Fani cost Odisha an official Rs 12,000 crore, and the milder Dana Rs 616 crore, destroying 1.8 lakh hectares of crops. By comparison, NCRMP spent about Rs 333 crore a year.

Jena gives three reasons the loss curve will not bend on its own. Agriculture takes the first hit: data from Cyclone Gulab show 70% of economic losses were crop damage, because storms strike the standing kharif paddy. Coastal States face different exposures, from rural housing in Odisha to horticulture and aquaculture in Andhra Pradesh. And insurance is almost absent: Swiss Re estimates 93% of India's catastrophe exposure is uninsured, so losses fall on households and State treasuries.

His answer is parametric insurance, which pays out on objective triggers such as recorded wind speed or rainfall instead of a months-long loss assessment. He suggests bundling it into PMFBY, the crop insurance scheme, in every coastal district. He also proposes restoring mangroves and wetlands that blunt storm surges, and shifting coastal farms to shorter-duration, cyclone-tolerant varieties.

Impact for India

  • Coastal farmers: bear most losses, with 70% of cyclone damage in crops, and could gain fast payouts from parametric cover.
  • State finances: uninsured losses land on treasuries; Amphan equalled 61% of West Bengal's budgeted revenue receipts.
  • Andhra Pradesh: puts Cyclone Arnab's preliminary loss at ₹4,600 crore.
  • Insurance regulation: Jena wants the three States to approach IRDAI and the NDMA for a pilot before April.

Key data

Fall in cyclone mortality since 1999: 99.8%1999 super cyclone: 9,885 deaths
Amphan loss to West Bengal: Rs 1 lakh crore61% of budgeted revenue receipts
NCRMP spending: Rs 4,331.68 crore over about 13 yearsAbout Rs 333 crore a year
India's catastrophe exposure uninsured (Swiss Re): 93%
Cyclone Arnab preliminary loss, Andhra Pradesh: ₹4,600 crore

Concepts

Parametric insuranceCover that pays a pre-agreed amount when a measurable trigger, such as wind speed, is crossed, without assessing each loss.Jena proposes bundling it into crop insurance enrolments in coastal districts.
Protection gapThe share of economic losses from disasters that is not covered by insurance.Swiss Re estimates 93% of India's catastrophe exposure is uninsured.
Risk poolingCombining many exposures so that losses in one place are paid from a common fund.Odisha, Andhra Pradesh and West Bengal would jointly finance a Bay of Bengal risk pool.

Theory lens

Risk pooling — insurance works by combining exposures whose losses do not all strike at once, so a common fund can pay whoever is hit. A single coastal State is a poor pool because one cyclone can hit most of it, which is why losses like Amphan's land on its treasury. Jena's three-State pool widens the base, and the parametric trigger cuts the cost of assessing claims, though it pays on the trigger rather than the exact loss.

Stakeholders

Gains: Coastal households and farmersParametric cover would pay within days of a storm instead of after months.
Pressure point: State treasuries in Odisha, Andhra Pradesh and West BengalWith 93% of catastrophe exposure uninsured, they absorb losses such as Amphan's Rs 1 lakh crore.

Practice Question — from the story

With reference to cyclone damage on India's east coast, consider the following statements:

  1. Mortality from storms of similar force has fallen 99.8% since 1999, and economic losses have fallen by a similar proportion.
  2. Swiss Re estimates that 93% of India's catastrophe exposure is insured.

Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

  1. 1 only
  2. 2 only
  3. Both 1 and 2
  4. Neither 1 nor 2
Reveal answer & explanation

Answer: Neither 1 nor 2

  • Statement 1: Incorrect. Deaths fell 99.8%, but Jena argues the economic loss curve remains untouched.
  • Statement 2: Incorrect. Swiss Re estimates 93% of the exposure is uninsured.

Therefore, the correct answer is Neither 1 nor 2.

Concept check — test your understanding

What distinguishes parametric insurance from traditional indemnity insurance?

  1. It is offered only by the government, so premiums are fully subsidised.
  2. It pays only after a field survey confirms each farmer's actual loss.
  3. It covers loss of life but not damage to crops or property.
  4. It pays a pre-agreed amount when a measurable trigger such as wind speed is crossed, without assessing each loss.
Reveal answer & explanation

Answer: D

  • Parametric cover pays on an objective trigger, which is why it can pay within days rather than after months of loss assessment.
  • A confuses the product with subsidy design; parametric cover can be private or public.
  • B describes traditional indemnity insurance, the slow process parametric cover avoids.
  • C is wrong: parametric cover is proposed precisely to protect livelihoods and crops.