Live on XaptiqUGC NET Economics (Dec 2026) and IIT JAM Economics (EN) test series are now live on Xaptiq.View test series
OpinionLabour > Structural TransformationIndian EconomyUnemploymentGrowth Vs Development

Growth without good jobs keeps India lower-middle income, argues Ishan Bakshi

India has been a lower-middle income country for 19 years because its workforce remains stuck in low-productivity farm and informal jobs, argues Ishan Bakshi of The Indian Express.

What happened

India's growth is not translating into productive jobs, argues Ishan Bakshi, senior associate editor at The Indian Express. India entered the World Bank's lower-middle income group in 2007 and remains there 19 years later. Vietnam took 16 years to move up and China 13. Bakshi writes that if incomes grew at 8.5% a year in dollar terms, against 5.4% over the past decade, India would reach today's upper-middle income threshold in around six years.

Context

Five countries, Jordan, Micronesia, the Philippines, Sri Lanka and Vietnam, moved up to the upper-middle income category this year. Vietnam crossed the lower-middle income threshold in 2009. China reached upper-middle income status in 2010. India's labour force grew by more than 100 million in less than a decade, according to the World Bank, while the unemployment rate trended lower. Bakshi's case is that low unemployment hides the real problem, which is the quality of the jobs.

Why it matters

Employment is not the same as productive employment, Bakshi argues. Poor workers cannot afford to stay unemployed, so they take whatever work exists. About two-thirds of the labour-force increase is women, most self-employed in agriculture. Some 43% of the labour force still works in agriculture, and 79% of the non-farm labour force is in informal enterprises, where value added is small.

The factory route to mass mobility has not worked. Registered factories doubled from 1.3 lakh in 2004-05 to 2.6 lakh in 2024-25, yet manufacturing's share of the economy and of employment has not risen. Between 2020-21 and 2024-25, fewer workers found jobs in formal manufacturing than in the gig economy. Production has become more capital-intensive, so wages per worker have grown more slowly than profits, weakening workers' bargaining power and widening inequality.

Two other links in the chain are weak. Public investment in highways, ports and freight corridors was meant to crowd in private investment, but companies have favoured returning money to shareholders. And solar capacity has run ahead of storage and transmission, making power supply a constraint on factories and data centres.

The gains are going to the top. India has 9.4 lakh dollar millionaires, according to the UBS Global Wealth Report, and could have a million by next year. Bakshi argues the economy is producing rich people faster than a broad middle class.

Impact for India

  • Workers: 43% remain in agriculture and 79% of non-farm workers are in informal enterprises, with low productivity and pay.
  • Manufacturing: factory numbers doubled without raising manufacturing's share of jobs or output.
  • Women: most of the new entrants to the labour force are self-employed in farming.
  • Private investment: companies have repaired balance sheets but are returning money to shareholders rather than investing broadly.
  • External account: more millionaires means more demand for foreign exchange for overseas education, investment and travel.

Key data

Years in lower-middle income group: 19 (India, since 2007)Vietnam 16 years; China 13 years
Labour force in agriculture: 43%
Non-farm labour force in informal enterprises: 79%
Registered factories: 2.6 lakh in 2024-251.3 lakh in 2004-05
Dollar income growth needed to reach upper-middle income in about six years: 8.5% a year5.4% over the past decade

Concepts

World Bank income classificationThe World Bank groups countries as low, lower-middle, upper-middle or high income by gross national income per person in dollars.India has been lower-middle income since 2007.
Informal sectorEnterprises and jobs outside formal regulation, typically without written contracts or social security.79% of the non-farm labour force works in informal enterprises.
Crowding inWhen public investment raises the return on private investment and so draws it in.Bakshi argues public infrastructure spending has not yet crowded in private capital.

Theory lens

Lewis dual-sector model — development happens as surplus labour moves from a low-productivity traditional sector to a high-productivity modern sector, raising average output per worker. Bakshi's figures show that transfer stalling in India: 43% of workers remain in agriculture, 79% of non-farm workers are informal, and the rise in registered factories has not lifted manufacturing's share of employment. Without that shift, growth enriches capital owners faster than it builds a middle class.

Stakeholders

Gains: Wealthy householdsIndia has 9.4 lakh dollar millionaires and could reach a million by next year.
Gains: Capital owners in manufacturingProfits have grown faster than wages per worker.
Pressure point: Informal and farm workersThey remain in low value-added work with weak bargaining power.

Practice Question — from the story

With reference to India's growth and employment pattern, consider the following statements:

  1. India entered the World Bank's lower-middle income group in 2007 and remains in it.
  2. Although registered factories doubled between 2004-05 and 2024-25, manufacturing's share of the economy and of employment has not risen.

Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

  1. 1 only
  2. 2 only
  3. Both 1 and 2
  4. Neither 1 nor 2
Reveal answer & explanation

Answer: Both 1 and 2

  • Statement 1: Correct. India entered the lower-middle income group in 2007 and remains there 19 years later.
  • Statement 2: Correct. Factories rose from 1.3 lakh to 2.6 lakh, yet manufacturing's share of output and jobs has not gone up.

Therefore, the correct answer is Both 1 and 2.

Concept check — test your understanding

In the Lewis dual-sector model, what drives development in an economy with surplus labour in agriculture?

  1. Raising farm incomes through support prices until they match industrial wages.
  2. Moving surplus labour from low-productivity traditional work into a high-productivity modern sector.
  3. Expanding self-employment in agriculture so that open unemployment falls.
  4. Increasing public infrastructure spending, which raises output per worker in every sector on its own.
Reveal answer & explanation

Answer: B

  • Lewis's model sees growth coming from the transfer of surplus farm labour into the modern sector, where each worker produces more.
  • A is an adjacent farm-policy instrument; higher farm incomes do not by themselves shift workers into higher productivity.
  • C is the trap the story describes: low unemployment can hide low-productivity work.
  • D is a partial truth: infrastructure helps, but the story argues it has not by itself crowded in private investment or factory jobs.