Live on XaptiqUGC NET Economics (Dec 2026) and IIT JAM Economics (EN) test series are now live on Xaptiq.View test series
OpinionAgriculture > Fertiliser SubsidyPublic FinanceSubsidiesAgriculture

Fixed urea price has worsened India's soil-nutrient imbalance, ICRIER economists argue

Keeping urea's price fixed while phosphate and potash prices float has pushed farmers to overuse nitrogen, argue Ashok Gulati and Ritika Juneja. They propose a per-hectare, nutrient-neutral cash subsidy.

What happened

Sixteen years after the nutrient-based subsidy (NBS) was introduced, the imbalance in farmers' use of nitrogen (N), phosphate (P) and potash (K) has worsened, argue Ashok Gulati and Ritika Juneja of the Indian Council for Research on International Economic Relations (ICRIER). Citing an ICRIER policy brief covering 20 major states from 2009-10 to 2024-25, they write that nitrogen use moved from 7% below its recommended dose to 6% above it. The potassium deficit deepened from 48 to 72%. The N:P:K ratio stands at 10.5:4.1:1, against a normative 2.8:1.5:1.

Context

The NBS reform of 2010 let the prices of phosphatic and potassic fertilisers float with world markets but kept urea at a fixed price. Between 2010-11 and 2024-25, di-ammonium phosphate (DAP) prices nearly tripled to Rs 54/kg and muriate of potash (MOP) rose six-fold to Rs 52/kg. The price of nitrogen in urea rose by just 1%. Nitrogen's share in NPK use is back to about 67%, the 1970-71 level. The authors were writing days after Agriculture Minister Shivraj Singh Chouhan launched his rabi campaign, Khet Bachao Abhiyan, on October 22, urging balanced fertiliser doses.

Why it matters

This is a case of a subsidy distorting relative prices. Farmers respond to the price of one nutrient against another. When urea stays cheap while DAP and MOP follow world prices, nitrogen becomes the cheapest way to make a crop look green. The damage from missing potash shows up later and quietly, so the signal farmers see is wrong.

The cost runs through soil, health and the budget. Of the 96 lakh samples tested under the Soil Health Card scheme in 2025-26, 72% were low in nitrogen and 52% low in organic carbon. Carbon-starved soils cannot hold what is applied, and crops take up only 30-40% of the nitrogen. Some escapes as nitrous oxide, a greenhouse gas 273 times as potent as carbon dioxide; some leaches into groundwater, and nitrate above safe limits has been found in parts of 502 districts.

The fiscal bill is large and skewed. The fertiliser subsidy budget for 2026-27 is Rs 1.71 lakh crore. The authors write that the Strait of Hormuz disruption could push it to between Rs 2.5 lakh crore and Rs 3 lakh crore, with urea taking two-thirds. Punjab gets about Rs 25,700 of nitrogen subsidy per hectare, 10 times what Kerala gets.

Impact for India

  • Union budget: the fertiliser subsidy, budgeted at Rs 1.71 lakh crore for 2026-27, could rise to between Rs 2.5 lakh crore and Rs 3 lakh crore with the Hormuz disruption, the authors estimate.
  • Farmers: cheap urea encourages nitrogen overuse while potash is under-applied in every state, hurting drought resistance and grain quality.
  • States: subsidy benefits are skewed, with Punjab getting about Rs 25,700 of nitrogen subsidy per hectare against a tenth of that in Kerala.
  • Groundwater and health: nitrate above safe limits in parts of 502 districts carries the risk of 'blue baby syndrome' in infants.
  • Climate: nitrous oxide from unused nitrogen adds to greenhouse emissions; Punjab's fertiliser-related emissions are nearly double the national average.

Key data

N:P:K use ratio: 10.5:4.1:1Normative 2.8:1.5:1
Potassium deficit against recommended dose: 72%Deepened from 482009-10 to 2024-25, 20 major states
Price change, 2010-11 to 2024-25: DAP nearly tripled to Rs 54/kg; MOP six-fold to Rs 52/kgNitrogen in urea up just 1%
Fertiliser subsidy budget, 2026-27: Rs 1.71 lakh croreCould reach between Rs 2.5 lakh crore and Rs 3 lakh crore with the Hormuz disruption
Soil Health Card samples low in nitrogen, 2025-26: 72% of 96 lakh52% low in organic carbon

Concepts

Nutrient-based subsidy (NBS)A fertiliser subsidy fixed per kilogram of nutrient (N, P, K) rather than per product, introduced in India in 2010.Urea was kept outside it at a fixed price, so only phosphate and potash prices moved with world markets.
Relative price distortionA gap between the prices users face and true costs that changes how they combine inputs.Nitrogen in urea rose just 1% in price while DAP nearly tripled, so farmers shifted towards nitrogen.
Direct benefit transfer (DBT)Paying a subsidy in cash to the beneficiary instead of lowering the price of the product.The authors propose a per-hectare transfer, neutral across nutrients and crops, so farmers face the market price of each nutrient.
N:P:K ratioThe proportion of nitrogen, phosphate and potash applied, compared with the proportion crops need.India's ratio of 10.5:4.1:1 is far from the normative 2.8:1.5:1.

Theory lens

Input substitution under distorted relative prices — producers choose the input mix where the ratio of marginal products equals the ratio of input prices. Fixing urea's price while DAP prices nearly tripled to Rs 54/kg and MOP rose six-fold to Rs 52/kg lowered nitrogen's relative price, so farmers substituted towards it. The result is an N:P:K ratio of 10.5:4.1:1 against a norm of 2.8:1.5:1, a misallocation the subsidy itself creates.

Historical parallel

The 2010 NBS reform — it was meant to fix nutrient imbalance by moving subsidies to a per-nutrient basis, but it kept urea out at a fixed price. By 2024-25 nitrogen's share in NPK use climbed back to about 67%, the 1970-71 level, the authors write, so a reform designed to correct the imbalance ended up deepening it.

Stakeholders

Gains: Farmers using balanced nutrientsA nutrient-neutral per-hectare transfer would stop penalising phosphate and potash use relative to urea.
Gains: Union exchequerThe authors propose capping the overall subsidy at around Rs 2 lakh crore while correcting relative prices.
Pressure point: Heavy urea users in Punjab and HaryanaThey receive the largest per-hectare nitrogen subsidy, which a nutrient-neutral transfer would remove.

Practice Question — from the story

With reference to India's nutrient-based subsidy (NBS) for fertilisers, consider the following statements:

  1. Under NBS, the price of urea was allowed to float with world markets while the prices of DAP and MOP were kept fixed.
  2. Between 2010-11 and 2024-25, DAP prices nearly tripled to Rs 54/kg while the price of nitrogen in urea rose by just 1%.

Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

  1. 1 only
  2. 2 only
  3. Both 1 and 2
  4. Neither 1 nor 2
Reveal answer & explanation

Answer: 2 only

  • Statement 1: Incorrect. It is the reverse: NBS let phosphatic and potassic fertiliser prices float with world markets but kept urea out at a fixed price.
  • Statement 2: Correct. DAP prices nearly tripled to Rs 54/kg between 2010-11 and 2024-25, while the price of nitrogen in urea rose by just 1%.

Therefore, the correct answer is 2 only.

Concept check — test your understanding

A government fixes the retail price of urea (a nitrogen fertiliser) while letting phosphate and potash prices follow world markets. If world phosphate and potash prices rise sharply, what does standard price theory predict?

  1. Farmers cut the use of all three nutrients in the same proportion, because crops need them in a fixed ratio
  2. Total fertiliser use falls, because the average price of fertiliser rises
  3. The subsidy bill falls, because farmers buy less of the imported phosphate and potash
  4. Farmers shift towards nitrogen, because its relative price falls, widening the gap from the recommended nutrient ratio
Reveal answer & explanation

Answer: D

  • Producers respond to relative input prices; when only urea is shielded, nitrogen becomes relatively cheaper and farmers substitute towards it, so the nutrient mix moves away from the norm.
  • A fixed agronomic ratio (A) would hold only if farmers could not substitute at all; in practice they do, as the overuse of nitrogen shows.
  • Average fertiliser prices may rise (B), but the substitution effect towards cheap nitrogen dominates the mix, so total use need not fall.
  • More urea use raises the urea subsidy, which is the largest part of the bill, so the total bill need not fall (C).