Bullet train cost nearly doubles to ₹2 lakh crore as India goes hybrid
The Mumbai-Ahmedabad bullet train's cost has nearly doubled to about ₹2 lakh crore from ₹1.08 lakh crore, and its first section is now due by December 2027 instead of 2022. India is replacing the all-Japanese design with Indian-built trains and European signalling.
What happened
The 508-km Mumbai-Ahmedabad High Speed Rail (MAHSR) project, begun in September 2017 with Japan and first estimated to finish by 2022, will open its first section by December 2027. The overall cost has nearly doubled to about ₹2 lakh crore against the initial estimate of ₹1.08 lakh crore, and the government is likely to allocate a special budget for the increase. The project is now a hybrid: Japanese track and civil design, European signalling and India-made trains. The signalling order, worth approximately ₹4,100 crore, has gone to a consortium of Dineshchandra R Agrawal Infracon, Siemens Ltd and Siemens Mobility GmbH. Japan's financing package remains in place.
Context
A Japanese feasibility study in December 2013 and a report in July 2015 shaped the idea; the Union Cabinet approved the project in December 2015. Japan financed it on highly concessional terms and expected to export the whole Shinkansen system, but India did not want to be tied to a single, high-cost imported solution, a senior industry source says. Delays followed: Covid-19, and uncertainty over land acquisition after Maharashtra's 2019 change of government, resolved only after the 2024 election. Japan phased out the E5 trainset meant for India, and the government decided in 2024 to build its own train once it was clear Japan could not supply the E10 before 2034.
Why it matters
The project shows how sequencing drives the cost of public megaprojects. The two sides announced timelines and costs "without sufficiently detailed homework and without taking into account risks", says the industry source, and execution details such as procurement, cost estimates and statutory approvals were worked out afterwards. Prudent execution, the source argues, means spending major capital only once statutory approvals and land rights are in place, because money already sunk is exposed to every later delay. The switch to a hybrid system is the second economic choice: cost effectiveness, flexibility and indigenisation of technology, especially for expanding high-speed rail beyond this corridor. The trade-off is technical risk. Masafumi Shukuri, Chairman of the International High-Speed Rail Association, says India will have to prove that two train types and signalling systems can run safely on one corridor.
Impact for India
- Union finances: a cost of about ₹2 lakh crore against ₹1.08 lakh crore is likely to need a special budget allocation.
- Domestic manufacturing: BEML in Bengaluru is building the Indian Bullet Train (B28), with a maximum operational speed of 250 kmph.
- Suppliers: the ₹4,100 crore signalling order includes Siemens Ltd's share of ₹1,230 crore, with 54 months to execute and 15 years of maintenance.
- Indian Railways: must make Japanese civil works, European signalling and Indian trains work together as one system.
- India-Japan ties: the concessional Japanese financing stays, and the two sides are likely to negotiate supply of the E10 trainset later.
Key data
Concepts
Theory lens
Optimism bias in megaproject planning — large public projects tend to be approved on timelines and cost estimates that assume few risks, so overruns are common rather than exceptional. The bullet train fits the pattern: timelines and costs were announced before detailed homework, procurement and approvals were sorted out later, and the cost has nearly doubled while the first section slipped from 2022 to December 2027.
Global context
Delays and overruns on high-speed rail are not unique to India. The source points to Japan's Shinkansen line to Hokkaido and the UK's High Speed 2 as similar projects that have seen substantive delays and cost overruns. The European Train Control System Level 2 signalling India has chosen is in operation in over 50 countries.
Stakeholders
Practice Question — from the story
With reference to the Mumbai-Ahmedabad High Speed Rail project, consider the following statements:
- The signalling contract for the project has been awarded to Japan's Shinkansen system providers.
- The Indian Bullet Train (B28) being developed by BEML has a maximum operational speed of 300 kmph.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
Reveal answer & explanation
Answer: Neither 1 nor 2
- Statement 1: Incorrect because the signalling order, worth approximately ₹4,100 crore, went to a consortium of Dineshchandra R Agrawal Infracon, Siemens Ltd and Siemens Mobility GmbH, using a European system rather than the Japanese one.
- Statement 2: Incorrect because the B28's maximum operational speed is 250 kmph; 300 kmph is the speed of Japan's Shinkansen trains.
Therefore, the correct answer is Neither 1 nor 2.
Concept check — test your understanding
An adviser argues that major capital on an infrastructure project should be spent only after statutory approvals and land rights are secured. Which economic risk does this sequencing mainly guard against?
Reveal answer & explanation
Answer: B
- Money already spent cannot be recovered, so starting works before approvals and land are secured leaves it stranded during any later delay, which is how such delays push up total cost.
- Crowding out concerns the effect of public borrowing on private investment; it does not depend on the order of approvals and spending.
- Currency risk on foreign loans is real for externally financed projects, but sequencing approvals does not change it.
- Demand risk concerns ridership after completion; it is not what securing land and approvals first protects against.