Lowest bidder walks away, stalling a 35.4 km Delhi-Mumbai Expressway stretch
The National Highways Authority of India (NHAI) is seeking bids a fourth time for a 35.4 km Gujarat stretch of the Delhi-Mumbai Expressway, after the lowest bidder, who quoted over 10% below the Rs 1,476 crore estimate, refused the award.
What happened
NHAI has issued a second call for bids for package 8, the 35.4 km Jujuwa-Gandeva section in Valsad and Navsari districts, after the lowest (L1) bidder, Bansal Construction Works, declined the letter of award. The firm had quoted over 10% less than the estimated project cost of Rs 1,476 crore, and NHAI encashed its bid security of Rs 14.76 crore. Bids closed on October 13. This is the fourth time NHAI has invited bids for the stretch, whose balance work is only 4.85% complete. Completion is now targeted for June 30, 2028.
Context
The 1,386-km expressway, in 53 packages across Delhi, Haryana, Rajasthan, Madhya Pradesh, Gujarat and Maharashtra, is being built at a cost of Rs 1.04 lakh crore. Of the Rs 1,03,636 crore project cost, Rs 71,718 crore had been spent by December 2025. Package 8 was first awarded in 2021 under the Hybrid Annuity Mode (HAM), terminated in March 2023, and re-awarded to the same contractor in November 2023 under Engineering, Procurement and Construction (EPC), before being terminated again. Nearby, package 9 is around 22% complete and package 10 has 36.23% physical progress.
Why it matters
The stretch shows how aggressive bidding can raise the real cost of public infrastructure. In a lowest-price tender, a firm that underbids may win a contract it cannot carry out. Each failed award adds a fresh tender cycle and more delay. The second-lowest bid here, from Ceigall India, was Rs 1,581 crore, above the estimate. NHAI's answer is contractual: a July 15 circular requires additional performance guarantees from bidders, so a firm that quotes too low has more at stake. The package has also moved between contract models. Under HAM the developer shares the financing burden, while under EPC the authority pays for construction and the contractor only builds.
Impact for India
- NHAI: another tender cycle for package 8, with the Rs 14.76 crore bid security forfeited by the L1 bidder.
- Contractors: the July 15 circular on additional performance guarantees raises the cost of quoting unrealistically low.
- Freight and road users: the full expressway is meant to cut the Delhi-Jawaharlal Nehru Port distance by 180 km and travel time by up to 50%, and three small Gujarat stretches adding up to 87 km are holding that back.
- Public investment: Rs 71,718 crore of the Rs 1,03,636 crore cost had been spent by December 2025, while the delayed packages defer the corridor's full use.
Key data
Concepts
Theory lens
Winner's curse in procurement auctions — when contracts go to the lowest bid, the winner is often the firm that most underestimated costs, and it may abandon the work once those costs become clear. Bansal Construction quoted over 10% below the Rs 1,476 crore estimate and then declined the award. NHAI's July 15 circular on additional performance guarantees raises the price of such a bid, which is the standard contractual fix for abnormally low tenders.
Stakeholders
Practice Question — from the story
With reference to package 8 of the Delhi-Mumbai Expressway, consider the following statements:
- NHAI encashed a bid security of Rs 14.76 crore after the lowest bidder declined the letter of award.
- The stretch was first awarded in 2021 under the Engineering, Procurement and Construction mode and later re-awarded under the Hybrid Annuity Mode.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
Reveal answer & explanation
Answer: 1 only
- Statement 1: Correct because the NHAI official said the bid security of Rs 14.76 crore was encashed under the request for proposal after Bansal Construction did not accept the award.
- Statement 2: Incorrect because it is the reverse: the stretch was first awarded under the Hybrid Annuity Mode in 2021 and re-awarded under the Engineering, Procurement and Construction mode in November 2023.
Therefore, the correct answer is 1 only.
Concept check — test your understanding
How does the Hybrid Annuity Mode (HAM) of highway contracting differ from the Engineering, Procurement and Construction (EPC) mode?
Reveal answer & explanation
Answer: A
- HAM splits the financing between the authority and the developer, who is repaid through annuities, whereas EPC is fully government-funded with the contractor bearing construction risk only.
- Toll collection with traffic risk describes the build-operate-transfer toll model, not HAM, and EPC contractors are paid for construction, not annuities.
- The choice between HAM and EPC depends on how financing and risk are shared, not on whether a multilateral lender is involved.
- This reverses the two models: the government pays part of the cost during construction under HAM and all of it under EPC.