Winding down KIIFB will set Kerala back a decade, argues Thomas Isaac
Kerala's capital spending is 1.34% of GSDP against an all-State average near 3%, and ending KIIFB's off-budget borrowing leaves no way to close the gap, argues former Finance Minister T.M. Thomas Isaac.
What happened
Kerala's Cabinet has accepted an expert committee report that conceded the Union government's charges against the Kerala Infrastructure Investment Fund Board (KIIFB), limiting the board to completing ongoing projects. Scrapping KIIFB will be a major policy blunder that pushes the State back by at least a decade, argues T.M. Thomas Isaac, who as Finance Minister made it the State's vehicle for infrastructure borrowing. Kerala's capital expenditure is only 1.34% of gross State domestic product (GSDP) even after an increase in the revised Budget, he writes, against an all-State average of nearly 3%.
Context
KIIFB was reorganised in 2016 to raise money for infrastructure outside the State Budget. Half the motor vehicle tax and petrol cess was guaranteed to it, and it securitised these future revenues to finance projects, under legislation passed unanimously by the Assembly. Isaac says it sanctioned projects worth more than ₹1 lakh crore in a decade. The Union government then alleged violations of the Constitution and the Fiscal Responsibility and Budget Management (FRBM) Act, and deducted KIIFB's loans from Kerala's borrowing space with retrospective effect. Kerala went to the Supreme Court.
Why it matters
The dispute is over what counts as State borrowing. States borrow within limits set by the Centre, and an off-budget body like KIIFB lets a State invest beyond its budget by borrowing against earmarked revenues. The Centre counted KIIFB's loans against Kerala's borrowing space. Isaac argues that a State pursuing a different development path must be able to work within, and stretch, a federal system he calls severely imbalanced. With KIIFB wound down, he says, neither the committee nor the government has offered another way to sustain infrastructure investment, and budget resources alone cannot close a capital-spending gap that has persisted for five decades.
Impact for India
- Kerala's infrastructure: KIIFB will only complete ongoing projects, with the government paying through loan repayments or contractors' bills.
- State finances: the retrospective deduction of KIIFB loans from the borrowing space seriously affected Kerala's budget balance, Isaac writes.
- Revenue-earning projects: 20%-25% of KIIFB projects already earn revenue; Isaac's alternative of turning KIIFB into a revenue-generating financing institution is now foreclosed.
- Capital spending: Kerala's capex stays at 1.34% of GSDP against nearly 3% for all States.
Key data
Concepts
Theory lens
Fiscal federalism and the soft budget constraint — when a lower level of government can borrow outside its budget, the higher level worries the debt will end up as its problem, so it caps every form of borrowing. Kerala's KIIFB borrowed against earmarked motor vehicle tax and petrol cess, and the Centre counted those loans against the State's borrowing space. Isaac argues this ignores the federal system's imbalance and leaves Kerala's capital spending at 1.34% of GSDP.
Stakeholders
Practice Question — from the story
With reference to the Kerala Infrastructure Investment Fund Board (KIIFB), consider the following statements:
- Kerala's capital expenditure is 1.34% of GSDP, against an all-State average of nearly 3%.
- Half the motor vehicle tax and petrol cess was guaranteed to KIIFB, which securitised these future revenues to finance projects.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
Reveal answer & explanation
Answer: Both 1 and 2
- Statement 1: Correct because Isaac cites Kerala's capital expenditure at 1.34% of GSDP even after the revised Budget, against an all-State average of nearly 3%.
- Statement 2: Correct because the 2016 reorganisation guaranteed KIIFB half the motor vehicle tax and petrol cess, and it securitised that revenue flow.
Therefore, the correct answer is Both 1 and 2.
Concept check — test your understanding
Why might the Union government count loans raised by a State-owned body such as KIIFB against the State's own borrowing limit?
Reveal answer & explanation
Answer: C
- KIIFB's loans were serviced from motor vehicle tax and petrol cess guaranteed by the State, so the Centre treated them as State borrowing and deducted them from Kerala's borrowing space.
- Option A is a misconception: KIIFB did borrow from the market, and the dispute is about how those loans are counted.
- Option B may be true of some off-budget bodies, but a higher interest rate is not the reason for counting the debt against the limit.
- Option D confuses levels of government: State-level borrowing counts in State deficits and the general government total, not directly in the Centre's own deficit.