Statistics ministry may use UPI data to measure health, education output
The statistics ministry has proposed measuring private health and education output from UPI payments, and public services from government salaries, to widen the new Index of Services Production (ISP) from about 60% of services value added to around 78%.
What happened
The Ministry of Statistics and Programme Implementation (MoSPI) has released an approach paper proposing to add education, health, and public administration and defence to the Index of Services Production (ISP), India's new monthly services output measure. Private output in education and health would be gauged from UPI payments, identified through Merchant Category Codes — the code for "taxi cabs and limousines" is 4121. Public provision would be measured from salaries drawn from the Public Financial Management System (PFMS). Comments are invited by October 16.
Context
The ISP is the services counterpart to the Index of Industrial Production and was released on an experimental basis starting July. It covers 19 sub-sectors and approximately 60% of the sector's gross value added in 2024-25, its base year. Health, education, and public administration and defence were left out because MoSPI had not settled a way to measure their output. A sub-committee of the ministry's Advisory Committee on National Accounts Statistics had decided in a February report against using payments data in GDP, saying UPI data were not yet stable with many people still using cash.
Why it matters
Services make up more than half of India's economy and have done for roughly the last decade and a half, while industry contributes less than a third of gross value added. Yet until the ISP there was no official monthly measure of services output — the only monthly read was S&P Global's private services Purchasing Managers' Index (PMI), a survey-based diffusion index rather than an official output series. The three sub-sectors now proposed for inclusion made up almost a fifth of services gross value added in 2024-25: education around 7%, human health and residential care around 3%, and public administration and defence almost 11%. Adding them lifts ISP coverage to around 78%. The method also marks a shift in how India measures output — from surveys and administrative returns towards transaction data generated as a by-product of payments.
Impact for India
- Statistical system: ISP coverage rises from approximately 60% to around 78% of services gross value added; the remaining 22% or so, from ownership of dwellings, the Reserve Bank of India, and gambling and betting among other activities, stays out.
- Policymakers: a monthly official services reading reduces reliance on the private services PMI when judging momentum in the largest part of the economy.
- Measurement risk: UPI captures only payments that have moved off cash, so a rising UPI share can read as output growth where it is really a shift in payment method — the objection the national accounts sub-committee raised in February.
- Public sector measurement: for public administration and defence, which are not market activities, MoSPI proposes adding employee compensation to operational expenses, an input-based measure rather than an output one.
Key data
Concepts
Theory lens
National income accounting by the production approach — output is measured sector by sector as gross value added, so a sector missing from the index is invisible to the monthly read even when it is large. The proposal shows the practical limit of that approach for non-market services: public administration and defence have no transaction value, so MoSPI falls back on inputs, adding employee compensation to operating expenses as a proxy for output.
Stakeholders
Practice Question — from the story
With reference to the Index of Services Production (ISP), consider the following statements:
- The ISP currently comprises 19 sub-sectors covering around 78% of the services sector's gross value added in its base year.
- Private output in education and health is proposed to be measured from UPI payments identified by Merchant Category Codes, and public provision from salaries drawn from the Public Financial Management System.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
Reveal answer & explanation
Answer: 2 only
- Statement 1: Incorrect because the ISP currently comprises 19 sub-sectors covering approximately 60% of the services sector's gross value added in 2024-25; around 78% is the coverage expected only after health, education, and public administration and defence are added.
- Statement 2: Correct because MoSPI's approach paper proposes exactly this split — UPI payments identified through Merchant Category Codes for the private side, and PFMS salary data for the public side.
Therefore, the correct answer is 2 only.
Concept check — test your understanding
Why did a national accounts sub-committee object to using UPI transaction data as an indicator of household consumption?
Reveal answer & explanation
Answer: C
- The objection was about the series not being stable: with many people yet to move from cash to UPI, a rise in UPI values can measure a change in payment method rather than a change in spending.
- Option A is a real limitation of person-to-merchant data, but a consumption indicator is meant to capture household rather than business spending.
- Option B sounds technical but Merchant Category Codes are precisely what MoSPI proposes to use for the mapping.
- Option D is a genuine practical mismatch in statistical work, but a higher-frequency source is an advantage rather than the stated objection.