SWIFT alternatives inch ahead as BRICS ties trade to national-currency payments
The BRICS New Delhi Declaration's push for more intra-bloc trade in national currencies has revived interest in SWIFT alternatives, but the leading contenders — China's CIPS, Russia's SPFS and Project mBridge — still settle only a fraction of dollar-clearing flows.
What happened
The BRICS Summit's New Delhi Declaration committed member-countries to expanding intra-bloc trade and settling more of it in national currencies. Days earlier, Reuters reported that India would push to link central bank digital currencies (CBDCs) for cross-border BRICS payments; the CBDC link did not make the final Declaration. Sberbank chief executive Herman Gref told a New Delhi briefing that CBDC-based settlement of India-Russia trade was 'much more efficient' than current arrangements.
Context
India and Russia have already built a functioning rupee-rouble payments infrastructure using 22 Russian banks (including Sberbank) and 17 Indian banks, which now handles 96% of bilateral trade, per Sberbank India head Ivan Nosov. This came after the 2022 SWIFT ban on Russian banks and Moscow's push to internationalise its own System for Transfer of Financial Messages (SPFS), formed in 2014, which added 50 new entities in 2023 to reach 440 members, of which more than 100 are non-residents.
Why it matters
Dollar clearing is the backbone of global trade because the US-based Clearing House Interbank Payments System (Chips) settles roughly $1.9 trillion a day of international payments. A rival system must reach settlement liquidity of comparable scale to be genuinely alternative — a bar even China's Cross-Border Interbank Payment System (CIPS), which processed 679.8 billion yuan ($98.7 billion) a day on average in 2025, has not cleared. This defines dedollarisation as a long-run monetary-system shift, not a one-summit policy switch.
Impact for India
- Bilateral trade: 96% of India-Russia trade is already settled in roubles/rupees outside SWIFT, insulating a large slice of energy imports from Western-payment restrictions.
- RBI: A CBDC-linked BRICS system would put the digital rupee into cross-border settlement rails; the CBDC-link proposal did not, however, make the New Delhi Declaration.
- CIPS access: India is the only BRICS member absent from CIPS's 120-country participant list, a policy choice worth watching as trade diversification accelerates.
- US leverage: The same week as the Declaration, the US Senate empowered the President to impose 100% tariffs on Russian-oil buyers, illustrating why alternatives remain in demand.
Key data
Concepts
Theory lens
Network externalities in money — the value of a payment system rises with each additional participant, which is why SWIFT and dollar clearing entrench even as alternatives emerge. CIPS's $98.7 billion a day is a small fraction of Chips's $1.9 trillion for exactly this reason: liquidity attracts more liquidity, and switching costs deter early defection unless political shocks (SWIFT ban on Russia, dollar-clearing weaponisation) force it.
Global context
CIPS has 120+ country participants, all BRICS members except India, helped by the renminbi's inclusion in the IMF's Special Drawing Rights basket. Project mBridge — Bank of Thailand, UAE, PBoC's Digital Currency Institute, HKMA and Saudi Central Bank — reached minimum viability status in 2024, but lost BIS support that October and now functions in practice as a renminbi-denominated wholesale rail for China-Gulf trade.
Stakeholders
Practice Question — from the story
With reference to alternatives to the SWIFT payment messaging system, consider the following statements:
- Russia's System for Transfer of Financial Messages (SPFS) was developed in 2014 to bypass Western sanctions.
- The Bank for International Settlements (BIS) exited Project mBridge, a multi-CBDC cross-border settlement platform, in October 2024.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
Reveal answer & explanation
Answer: Both 1 and 2
- Statement 1: Correct because Russia developed SPFS in 2014 explicitly to bypass Western sanctions; it proved useful when Russian banks were cut off from SWIFT in 2022.
- Statement 2: Correct because the BIS exited Project mBridge on October 31, 2024 after hand-holding it since 2019; the platform had attained minimum viability status the same year.
Therefore, the correct answer is Both 1 and 2.
Concept check — test your understanding
The size gap between CIPS (roughly $98.7 billion cleared daily) and Chips (roughly $1.9 trillion cleared daily) is often explained by 'network externalities' in payment systems. Which of the following best captures why?
Reveal answer & explanation
Answer: B
- Network externalities describe positive feedback loops in which each new participant makes a network more valuable to future joiners. In cross-border payments, liquidity concentrates on the incumbent because access to counterparties is what matters, which is why CIPS remains a fraction of Chips despite years of Beijing's push.
- Distractor A confuses network effects with a pricing choice; even zero-fee alternatives struggle to attract volume when counterparties sit elsewhere.
- Distractor C is factually loose — CIPS is being built for multi-currency settlement, and SWIFT itself is a messaging, not a settlement, layer.
- Distractor D describes an imaginary rule; the BIS in fact incubated Project mBridge before exiting it.