Tamil Nadu's sustainable debt-GSDP ratio is 23%, says state's economic consultant
Tamil Nadu's debt-to-GSDP ratio should be brought down from 27% to a sustainable 23%, argues K.R. Shanmugam, the State's economic consultant, three percentage points above the FRBM Committee's general 20% ceiling for States.
What happened
K.R. Shanmugam, economic consultant to the Tamil Nadu government, said the sustainable debt-GSDP (gross state domestic product) ratio for the State is 23% and pressed for a reduction from the existing 27%. The FRBM (Fiscal Responsibility and Budget Management) Committee headed by N.K. Singh, in its 2017 report, prescribed a 20% prudent limit for States generally. Shanmugam argued Tamil Nadu could carry an additional three percentage points given macroeconomic progress over the last five years. He also flagged that the State's revenue deficit at about 1.4% of GSDP means nearly 50% of borrowed funds go to consumption, not investment.
Context
Tamil Nadu's debt-GSDP ratio was 22.78% in 2019-20 before the COVID-19 pandemic pushed it to 28.67% in 2020-21, from where it has ranged between 26% and 28%. Only three States — Gujarat, Odisha, and Maharashtra — have ratios below the 20% mark. Nine States, including Andhra Pradesh, Bihar, Kerala, Punjab, Rajasthan, Telangana, Uttar Pradesh, and West Bengal, have higher ratios than Tamil Nadu. The State has held its fiscal deficit at 3% of GSDP, in line with the FRBM path, but stubborn revenue deficits have kept the debt stock elevated post-pandemic.
Why it matters
Debt is not intrinsically bad — when borrowed money funds productive assets like infrastructure, the resulting growth services the debt. The trouble starts when the debt-GSDP ratio crosses the prudent level: interest payments crowd out productive spending and can trigger a debt trap. The 1.4% revenue deficit is the clearest warning sign for Tamil Nadu — half of new borrowing is financing today's wages, subsidies, and running costs, not tomorrow's income-generating assets. That mix is what turns a manageable debt stock into an unsustainable one.
Impact for India
- Tamil Nadu Treasury: To reach 23% by 2050-51 the State needs 15% nominal growth annually with the fiscal deficit held at 3%; a faster glide to 23% by 2033-34 would need the deficit trimmed to 2.5% with 14% nominal growth.
- State welfare programmes: Shanmugam has explicitly warned against implementing the ruling Tamilaga Vettri Kazhagam's promise of raising the Magalir Urimai Thogai monthly cash transfer from ₹1,000 to ₹2,500 for all women up to age 60 until consolidation is achieved.
- Nine higher-debt States: Andhra Pradesh, Bihar, Kerala, Madhya Pradesh, Punjab, Rajasthan, Telangana, Uttar Pradesh, and West Bengal carry ratios above Tamil Nadu's — the same crowding-out logic applies with greater force.
- Union Finance Ministry: State-level debt sustainability sits inside the wider N.K. Singh FRBM framework that anchors borrowing ceilings for both the Centre and the States.
Key data
Concepts
Theory lens
Domar debt sustainability — a public debt stock stays stable relative to output only when the nominal growth rate exceeds the effective interest rate on debt, with the primary balance filling any remaining gap. Shanmugam's arithmetic — 15% nominal growth plus a 3% fiscal deficit taking TN to 23% by 2050-51, or 14% growth plus a 2.5% deficit reaching it by 2033-34 — is a direct application: faster growth or a tighter primary balance shrinks the debt-GSDP ratio faster.
Stakeholders
Practice Question — from the story
With reference to Tamil Nadu’s debt-GSDP ratio debate covered in the news, consider the following statements:
- The N.K. Singh FRBM Committee (2017) prescribed 23% as the prudent debt-GSDP limit for the States in general.
- Tamil Nadu’s revenue deficit at about 3% of GSDP means nearly 50% of borrowed funds are spent on investment rather than consumption.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
Reveal answer & explanation
Answer: Neither 1 nor 2
- Statement 1: Incorrect because the FRBM Committee headed by N.K. Singh, in its 2017 report, prescribed 20% as the prudent debt-GSDP limit for the States in general. The consultant argues Tamil Nadu could carry 23% specifically, three percentage points above the general limit.
- Statement 2: Incorrect because Tamil Nadu’s revenue deficit is about 1.4% of GSDP (its fiscal deficit is 3%), and the 50% figure refers to borrowed money being spent on consumption rather than investment, not the other way around.
Therefore, the correct answer is Neither 1 nor 2.
Concept check — test your understanding
Under the standard Domar condition of public-debt sustainability, the debt-to-GDP ratio stops rising over time when:
Reveal answer & explanation
Answer: B
- The Domar/textbook debt-dynamics identity shows that the debt-GDP ratio stops rising when the nominal growth rate (g) matches or exceeds the effective interest rate (r) on outstanding debt, once the primary balance is zero. Shanmugam’s scenarios for Tamil Nadu — 15% nominal growth with the fiscal deficit held at 3%, or 14% growth with 2.5% — rely on exactly this g > r logic.
- Option A confuses a zero primary deficit with debt-ratio stability; if r > g, the ratio can still climb even with a zero primary deficit because interest itself compounds the stock.
- Option C is a solvency misconception: sustainability is about flows (interest vs growth), not a one-year stock-versus-revenue comparison.
- Option D confuses a flow ceiling (fiscal deficit) with the stock outcome (debt ratio); the FRBM path bounds new borrowing but does not by itself stabilise the debt-GDP ratio if growth undershoots interest.