PSBs are more efficient than private banks, EAC-PM paper finds
An EAC-PM paper using data envelopment analysis finds public sector banks operated at 93.12% efficiency in 2025-26, ahead of private banks at 86.02% and foreign banks at 85.88%, and calls for further PSB consolidation into a few large banks of equal size.
What happened
An Economic Advisory Council to the PM paper by SBI's Group Chief Economic Advisor Soumya Kanti Ghosh and economist Tapas Kumar Parida used data envelopment analysis to score 47 banks over 2014-15 to 2025-26. It found public sector banks operated at 93.12% efficiency in 2025-26, above private banks at 86.02% and foreign banks at 85.88%. Over the 12-year period, PSBs averaged 88.53% against private banks' 85.62% and foreign banks' 88.98%, though foreign bank efficiency fell sharply from 95.86% in 2014-15.
Context
The paper follows two rounds of PSB consolidation. In January 2019 the Cabinet cleared the merger of Vijaya Bank, Dena Bank, and Bank of Baroda, and in March 2020 a larger consolidation absorbed Oriental Bank of Commerce and United Bank of India into Punjab National Bank, Syndicate Bank into Canara Bank, Andhra Bank and Corporation Bank into Union Bank of India, and Allahabad Bank into Indian Bank. The number of PSBs came down to 12. Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman recently told PSB officials they had to raise their 'cool' quotient in the eyes of the country's youth without sacrificing prudence.
Why it matters
In banking, efficiency measures how much output — loans, deposits, fee income — a bank produces from its inputs of capital, labour and physical infrastructure. A DEA score of 93.12% for PSBs versus 86.02% for private banks means PSBs are on average using their inputs more productively today. That challenges a long-standing narrative that governance rigidities make state-owned banks structurally slower. The finding also matters for policy sequencing: if PSBs are more efficient than private banks, further mergers become a scale story rather than a governance rescue.
Impact for India
- PSBs: The paper strengthens the argument for turning them into fewer, larger banks of equal size rather than privatising them.
- Private banks: Efficiency score of 86.02% in 2025-26 keeps competitive pressure on them, especially HDFC Bank which led among private lenders at 97.54% over 12 years.
- Foreign banks: Efficiency fell from 95.86% in 2014-15 to 85.88% in 2025-26, narrowing their historical edge over Indian banks.
- IDBI Bank: Stands seventh most efficient over 12 years, complicating the ongoing privatisation pitch.
- Credit supply: Larger, efficient PSBs are the mechanism the paper backs to meet the 2047 developed-nation credit demand.
Key data
Concepts
Theory lens
Structure-conduct-performance framework — the productivity of banks depends jointly on ownership structure, competitive conduct, and scale. Under this lens, DEA scores treat ownership as one input among many rather than as a proxy for governance. If Indian PSBs sit above private peers in 2025-26, it suggests post-consolidation scale and technology adoption have offset the classical agency-cost disadvantages of state ownership, and that further mergers into a few equal-sized PSBs could push the frontier out without sacrificing market competition.
Stakeholders
Practice Question — from the story
With reference to the EAC-PM paper on efficiency of Indian banks by ownership type, consider the following statements:
- The paper found that private sector banks operated at an efficiency of 93.12% in 2025-26, ahead of public sector banks at 86.02%.
- The efficiency of foreign banks operating in India rose from 85.88% in 2014-15 to 95.86% in 2025-26.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
Reveal answer & explanation
Answer: Neither 1 nor 2
- Statement 1: Incorrect because the paper attributes 93.12% to PSBs and 86.02% to private banks — the ownership types are swapped.
- Statement 2: Incorrect because the direction is reversed — foreign bank efficiency fell from 95.86% in 2014-15 to 85.88% in 2025-26.
Therefore, the correct answer is Neither 1 nor 2.
Concept check — test your understanding
In data envelopment analysis (DEA), what does an efficiency score of 85% for a commercial bank mean?
Reveal answer & explanation
Answer: D
- DEA scores each unit against a best-performing frontier — a score of 85% means the same output could in principle be produced with 85% of the observed input mix, i.e. inputs can be trimmed by 15%.
- Option A confuses an efficiency ratio with a profitability ratio; return-on-assets is a separate accounting metric.
- Option B mistakes efficiency for market share, which measures scale, not productivity.
- Option C is an adjacent-but-wrong instrument — Basel capital adequacy is a solvency measure, not a DEA productivity score.