SC's nine-judge bench keeps 1978 'triple test' for old labour cases, leaves new Code open
A nine-judge Supreme Court bench, in a fractured five-opinion verdict, kept the 1978 Bangalore Water Supply 'triple test' as the governing definition of 'industry' for pending Industrial Disputes Act cases, while ruling that the new Industrial Relations Code, 2020 must be read on its own terms — which explicitly exclude charities, domestic services and sovereign government functions.
What happened
A nine-judge Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court has ended a decades-long debate over what counts as an 'industry' under Indian labour law. The verdict runs to five separate opinions that differ sharply on interpretation, but converge on the practical outcome. Pending proceedings under the repealed Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 will continue to be decided under the 1978 'triple test' laid down by a seven-judge bench in Bangalore Water Supply and Sewerage Board vs A Rajappa. The new Industrial Relations Code, 2020 — which explicitly excludes charitable and philanthropic institutions, domestic services and sovereign government functions from the definition of 'industry' — must be interpreted independently on its own text and scheme.
Context
The dispute centres on Section 2(j) of the erstwhile Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 which defined 'industry' in broad terms, and the 1978 Bangalore Water Supply ruling that whether an undertaking is an industry depends on three things: systematic activity, cooperation between employer and employee, and the production or distribution of goods or services calculated to satisfy human wants and wishes — with the profit motive held irrelevant. That expansive interpretation came under pressure quickly. Parliament passed the Industrial Disputes (Amendment) Act, 1982 to exclude hospitals, educational and research institutions, charities and certain government activities, but the amended definition was never notified and never took effect. A five-judge bench referred the matter to a larger bench in 2005 (Jai Bir Singh); a seven-judge bench in 2017 sent it to the current nine-judge bench.
Why it matters
The stakes are the reach of India's protective labour statutes. A wide definition of 'industry' — as under the 1978 triple test — brings hospitals, universities, charitable bodies and welfare-oriented government functions within the ambit of the Industrial Disputes Act, giving their workers access to statutory protections against arbitrary dismissal, retrenchment and unresolved industrial disputes. A narrower reading — the CJI's proposed 'calibration' requiring a 'discernible commercial character' — would leave many of those workers to be governed by service rules and administrative discretion. By holding the 1978 test for pending cases but declining to carry it forward as the governing interpretation of the new Code, the bench avoids reopening decades of settled proceedings while leaving Parliament's own carve-outs in the Industrial Relations Code, 2020 — which excludes charities, domestic services and sovereign functions — to operate on their own terms.
Impact for India
- Workers in cases still pending under the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947: Continue to enjoy the expansive coverage of the 1978 triple test — protection turns on the nature of the activity, not on whether the employer runs for profit.
- Workers coming under the Industrial Relations Code, 2020: Statutory protections do not extend to charitable and philanthropic institutions, domestic workers, or sovereign government functions, which the Code explicitly excludes.
- Charities, hospitals and educational institutions: For older disputes, they remain within the scope of the 1978 test; for disputes under the new Code, they are outside its definition of 'industry'.
- State (as employer of welfare-scheme workers): The judgment reaffirms that an activity does not become sovereign merely because it is performed by the government — only core, inalienable functions qualify — closing an argument that could have taken large welfare workforces outside labour law.
- Domestic workers: Explicit exclusion under the new Code confirms they fall outside the industrial disputes framework and would need bespoke protection elsewhere.
Key data
Concepts
Theory lens
Institutional economics of labour regulation — the extent of protective labour law tracks a legislative choice about which employment relationships face market-based risk and which are cushioned by statutory floors. The 1978 triple test settled the boundary broadly, treating employer profit motive as irrelevant because worker exposure to job insecurity, arbitrary dismissal and unpaid wages does not depend on whether the employer is a hospital, a school, or a factory. The Industrial Relations Code, 2020 redraws that boundary narrower — carving out charities, domestic services and sovereign functions — reflecting a policy judgment that these relationships should be governed by service rules, contract law or bespoke statutes rather than the industrial-disputes machinery.
Stakeholders
Practice Question — from the story
With reference to the recent nine-judge Supreme Court verdict on the definition of 'industry' under labour law, consider the following statements:
- Pending proceedings under the repealed Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 will continue to be decided under the 1978 'triple test' laid down in Bangalore Water Supply and Sewerage Board vs A Rajappa.
- The Industrial Relations Code, 2020 explicitly excludes charitable and philanthropic institutions, domestic services and sovereign government functions from its definition of 'industry'.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
Reveal answer & explanation
Answer: Both 1 and 2
- Statement 1: Correct. All five opinions agree that pending Industrial Disputes Act cases will continue to be decided under the 1978 Bangalore Water Supply triple test.
- Statement 2: Correct. Unlike the old Act, the Industrial Relations Code, 2020 explicitly excludes charitable and philanthropic institutions, domestic services and sovereign government functions from the definition of 'industry'.
Therefore, the correct answer is Both 1 and 2.
Concept check — test your understanding
The 1978 Bangalore Water Supply 'triple test' held that whether an undertaking is an 'industry' does not depend on the presence of a profit motive. What is the primary economic rationale for keeping the profit motive irrelevant when deciding the reach of protective labour law?
Reveal answer & explanation
Answer: B
- Protective labour statutes target the employer-worker relationship, not the ownership form; a nurse in a charitable hospital and a nurse in a private hospital face the same risks of unpaid wages or arbitrary dismissal, so the statute's welfare purpose applies to both.
- A: The proxy claim is factually thin — profit motive does not track firm size, and small-firm exemptions in Indian labour law depend on employee thresholds, not the profit motive.
- C: Anti-avoidance is a legitimate concern, but it is a secondary administrative rationale; the substantive welfare argument in Bangalore Water Supply came first.
- D: Article 300A is a general property protection; there is no doctrine that dropping the profit test brings labour law within its ambit.