Supreme Court unshackles Industrial Relations Code from 1978 'industry' precedent
A nine-judge Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court has held that the 1978 Bangalore Water Supply definition of 'industry' will not automatically apply to the Industrial Relations Code, 2020, giving the new labour regime a clean slate that trade unions warn tilts jurisprudence toward employers.
What happened
A nine-judge Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court held that the interpretation of the term 'industry' laid down in its 1978 Bangalore Water Supply & Sewerage Board v. R. Rajappa & Others judgment will not automatically apply to the Industrial Relations Code (IRC), 2020, which replaced the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 when it came into force in November 2025. Left-leaning trade unions — AITUC, CITU and TUCI — publicly warned that the ruling reflects 'a structural tilt' toward institutional and managerial interests. AITUC general secretary Amarjeet Kaur said Justice Nagarathna questioned the necessity of reopening settled jurisprudence, and cautioned that Section 2(p) exclusions for 'sovereign functions' and charitable, social or philanthropic institutions require strict and constitutionally compatible interpretation.
Context
The 1978 Bangalore Water Supply judgment, delivered by a seven-judge bench led by Justice V.R. Krishna Iyer, laid down the 'triple test' for 'industry': systematic activity, employer-employee relationship, and production or distribution of goods or services for human wants — with no profit-motive requirement. CITU general secretary Elamaram Kareem said the current ruling gives the IRC immunity from that expansive definition. In an economy characterised by privatisation, outsourcing, contractualisation and public-private partnerships, unions argue that shifting focus from the substance of work to the institutional status of the employer can disadvantage labour.
Why it matters
Whether a workplace is an 'industry' determines whether workers there can claim protections under the country's labour law — collective bargaining rights, dispute-resolution machinery, and the applicability of the IRC. Severing the 2020 Code from the 1978 precedent leaves crucial definitional questions to future litigation, at exactly the moment when contractual, gig and outsourced work is expanding. The economics behind the labour codes is a bet that a narrower 'industry' definition will lower compliance costs and formalise employer discretion; unions argue it undermines the bargaining power of workers.
Impact for India
- Workers in charitable, social and philanthropic bodies: Exclusions from Section 2(p) may narrow coverage; unions want strict, constitutionally compatible interpretation.
- Government departments and PSUs: The 'sovereign functions' exclusion becomes a live boundary question — governmental activity is not automatically sovereign function.
- Employers under IRC, 2020: A clean slate on the definition of 'industry' reduces exposure to expansive 1978 jurisprudence when disputes arise.
- Trade unions: AITUC, CITU and TUCI have publicly opposed the ruling; further litigation on unresolved definitional questions is likely.
- Labour market formalisation agenda: Narrower 'industry' scope shapes how contractualisation, outsourcing and PPP arrangements are treated for labour law purposes.
Key data
Concepts
Theory lens
Institutional economics of labour markets — labour outcomes depend not only on supply and demand but on the enforceable rules that govern who is a worker, what a workplace is, and which disputes are subject to formal resolution. Narrowing the statutory definition of 'industry' effectively shifts bargaining leverage between employers and workers by shrinking the set of workplaces where the labour code's compliance costs and dispute machinery apply. This is the mechanism through which a definitional ruling shows up as a real-economy distributive change.
Stakeholders
Practice Question — from the story
With reference to the Supreme Court's recent ruling on the definition of 'industry' and the Industrial Relations Code, 2020, consider the following statements:
- The 1978 Bangalore Water Supply & Sewerage Board v. R. Rajappa & Others judgment on the definition of 'industry' was delivered by a nine-judge bench of the Supreme Court.
- The Industrial Relations Code, 2020 came into force in November 2020 and replaced the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
Reveal answer & explanation
Answer: Neither 1 nor 2
- Statement 1: Incorrect — the 1978 judgment was delivered by a seven-judge bench led by Justice V.R. Krishna Iyer. It is the current 2026 ruling that is by a nine-judge bench.
- Statement 2: Incorrect — while the IRC, 2020 replaced the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, it came into force in November 2025, not November 2020.
Therefore, the correct answer is Neither 1 nor 2.
Concept check — test your understanding
In labour economics, why does the statutory definition of what counts as an 'industry' — the set of workplaces covered by industrial-relations law — matter for the bargaining power of workers relative to employers?
Reveal answer & explanation
Answer: C
- Labour codes only bind employer conduct in workplaces that fall within their statutory scope. If a workplace is not an 'industry', collective bargaining machinery, dispute resolution and standing-order protections do not apply, and workers must rely on general civil or contract law — a weaker position. That is why unions warn the SC's narrower reading of Section 2(p) has real distributive consequences even before any particular dispute is decided.
- A confuses definitional scope with wage-fixation authority; the Code does not cap wages.
- B fabricates a non-existent link between the definition and union borrowing.
- D confuses labour law with corporate tax law.