SHANTI Act rules on foreign reactors tilt SMR field toward Rosatom
Draft rules under the SHANTI Act require imported nuclear technology to already be operational abroad — a clause that hands Russia's Rosatom, the only firm with a commercially operating small modular reactor design, a head start over Western challengers still in certification.
What happened
The Department of Atomic Energy has issued draft rules for the Sustainable Harnessing and Advancement of Nuclear Energy for Transforming India (SHANTI) Act. The rules require that any foreign nuclear technology sourced for a nuclear power plant or reactor in India must have its design certified or approved by the regulatory body in its country of origin, and must already be operational there or in another foreign country. In the nascent small modular reactor (SMR) field, only two projects globally have reached operational stage: Russia's Akademik Lomonosov floating power unit with two 35 MWe modules, in commercial operation since May 2020, and China's HTR-PM demonstration project, grid-connected in December 2021 and in commercial operation since December 2023.
Context
Rosatom's SMR pitch sits alongside a broader push to sell India its new-generation VVER-1200 reactors and to expand the Kudankulam plant, whose VVER-1000 units connected to the grid in 2013 and 2016. Western SMR contenders — Holtec International, Rolls-Royce SMR, NuScale's VOYGR, Westinghouse's AP300 and GE-Hitachi's BWRX-300 — are still in the design certification phase and none is operational. On large reactors too, cost tilts the field: industry insiders peg indigenous pressurised heavy water reactors (PHWRs) at around Rs 18 crore per MW-electric versus about Rs 34 crore per MW-electric for Russian reactors, and higher again for French and US light water reactors.
Why it matters
The rule is framed as a safety filter but works as an industrial-policy filter. India wants SMRs to power energy-hungry data centres and to add baseload capacity to remote grids, but the operational-elsewhere clause will admit only vendors whose reactors are already deployed abroad. Right now that's essentially Rosatom for SMRs. It also compounds Russia's incumbency in large reactors at Kudankulam, where Rosatom's fuel company TVEL supplies TVC-2M fuel enabling an 18-month cycle against a traditional 12-month cycle. The clause converts a nascent global market into a two-vendor race in India, with policy — not price alone — pushing Rosatom ahead.
Impact for India
- SMR deployment in India: near-term entry realistically limited to Rosatom, since Western SMR designs are still pre-operational; a delayed or narrower vendor pool for data-centre and remote-grid applications
- Domestic PHWR programme: unaffected by the rule (indigenous designs sit outside the foreign-technology clause) and retains its cost advantage at around Rs 18 crore per MW-electric vs about Rs 34 crore for Russian reactors
- India-Russia nuclear cooperation: the SMR framework adds to a pipeline already anchored by the Kudankulam project's six planned VVER-1000 units totalling 6,000 MWe, and by the proposed VVER-1200 negotiations
- Western vendors (Holtec, Rolls-Royce SMR, NuScale, Westinghouse, GE-Hitachi): India entry effectively deferred until each design achieves operational status in a home or foreign market
- Data-centre operators seeking captive baseload power: dependence on a single foreign vendor for SMRs raises procurement concentration risk
Key data
Concepts
Theory lens
Structure-conduct-performance (SCP) with an emphasis on regulatory entry barriers — the SCP framework treats market structure (concentration, entry conditions) as the primary determinant of firm conduct and industry performance, and treats regulation as a lever that can raise or lower entry barriers. Here the SHANTI Act's operational-elsewhere clause raises the entry barrier for SMRs from 'design certified at home' to 'design already commercially operating', which today only Rosatom clears; the resulting expected market structure is a near-monopoly for foreign SMRs in India, with conduct and performance implications flowing directly from that.
Stakeholders
Practice Question — from the story
With reference to India's SHANTI Act draft rules on foreign nuclear technology and the current state of small modular reactor (SMR) deployment, consider the following statements:
- The draft rules require foreign nuclear technology sourced for a plant or reactor in India to have its design certified or approved by the regulatory body in its country of origin, and to already be operational there or in another foreign country.
- The 'Akademik Lomonosov' floating nuclear power unit, which entered commercial operation in May 2020, is a two-module facility with each module rated at 1,000 MWe.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
Reveal answer & explanation
Answer: 1 only
- Statement 1: Correct. The draft rules state that foreign nuclear technology sourced for a nuclear power plant or reactor in India must have its design certified or approved by the regulatory body in its country of origin and must already be operational there or in another foreign country.
- Statement 2: Incorrect. The Akademik Lomonosov's two modules are rated at 35 MWe each, not 1,000 MWe. The 1,000 MWe figure in the source belongs to the VVER-1000 reactors at Kudankulam.
Therefore, the correct answer is 1 only.
Concept check — test your understanding
The SHANTI Act draft rule that a foreign small modular reactor (SMR) design must already be operational in its country of origin (or another foreign country) before it can enter India functions economically as which of the following?
Reveal answer & explanation
Answer: D
- The correct option reads the operational-elsewhere clause through structure-conduct-performance: it is a regulatory entry barrier that binds against firms whose designs are still in certification and admits only firms whose reactors are already deployed abroad — today, essentially only Rosatom for SMRs.
- Option A misreads the clause as a Pigouvian tax; there is no charge on risk, only a binary certification cutoff.
- Option B mislabels a regulatory admission rule as a subsidy; the rule transfers no money and if anything raises the effective cost of foreign SMR entry.
- Option C confuses the clause with a local-content mandate — a familiar instrument in PLI and defence procurement — but the SHANTI rule speaks to where the design must already work, not how much of the reactor must be built inside India.